×

Tata Punch vs Renault Kiger: Comparing Petrol-Manual Performance And Fuel Efficiency


While one gets a naturally aspirated motor with a higher displacement, the other has a turbocharger. Which one’s the better petrol-manual setup?

 

The Tata Punch and Renault Kiger are two similarly priced SUVs. But besides that, there are a couple of things common between the two. Both are petrol-only offerings, paired with a 5-speed manual as standard. The question is, which is the better petrol-manual combination of the two? 

We find out in this comparison: 

 

Specifications

 
 

Tata Punch 1.2-litre N.A

Renault Kiger 1-litre Turbo

Power (PS)

86PS 

100PS

Torque (Nm)

113Nm  

160Nm

Transmission 

5-speed MT

5-speed MT

While the Punch’s petrol engine has a slightly higher displacement than the Kiger, the latter has a turbocharger. On paper, it is the Kiger that holds a 14PS/47Nm advantage over the Punch. So does this theoretical advantage translate to real life? We got out the VBox to see that for ourselves.

 

Performance Runs

 

Tata Punch 1.2-litre N.A

Renault Kiger 1-litre Turbo (WET)

0-100kmph

16.81 seconds

11.01 seconds

40-100kmph (Fourth gear)

21.54 seconds

16.34 seconds

The Punch’s lack of grunt does affect its performance; the micro-SUV is slower than the Kiger while accelerating from a standstill and flooring when in motion. In fact, the difference could be more significant, considering the Kiger was tested in less-than-optimal conditions. 

 

Fuel Economy

 
 

Tata Punch 1.2-litre N.A

Renault Kiger 1-litre Turbo (WET)

City

13.86kmpl

15.33kmpl

Highway

17.08kmpl 

19kmpl 

Despite the superior performance, the Kiger doesn’t compromise on frugality. It comes out on top here, returning 15.33kmpl within the city and 19kmpl on the highway. The Punch managed 13.86kmpl in the city and 17.08kmpl on the highway.

 

Price

 

 

Tata Punch 1.2-litre N.A MT

Renault Kiger 1-litre Turbo MT

Ex-showroom Price

Rs 5.49 lakh (Pure) to Rs 8.49 lakh (Creative)

Rs 8.12 Lakh (RXT Turbo) to Rs  9.21 lakh  (RXZ Turbo DT)

Taking everything into consideration, if you’re willing to sacrifice some performance and frugality for a more affordable offering, the Punch is the better pick. The fact that this petrol-manual setup is offered in all four trims is undoubtedly a plus. On the other hand, if you are okay shelling out more for improved performance and frugality, go for the Kiger. That said, remember that the petrol-manual combine is offered only in the Kiger's RXT and RXZ trims. 

Tata Punch
4.4
Write Review & Win iPhone
Rs. 5.82 Lakh
View May Offers

See what our community has to say! NEW

India's largest automotive community

Explore Now
comminity image

4 Other Things You Might Want To Do