×

Tata Punch vs Maruti Suzuki Ignis AMT: Which One Is Quicker And More Frugal?


To find that out, we strapped our VBox and headed to our test location, and here are the results

ZW-Tata-Punch-Maruti-Ignis

The Tata Punch and Maruti Suzuki Ignis tick all the right boxes if you want your car to be more than just a regular hatchback. The two get jacked-up styling, a decent feature list, and an optional AMT transmission for convenience in the city.  

But which of the two is quicker and less fuel-thirsty in the real world? We found that out, and here are the numbers that matter. 

But before that, the specs:

 

Tata Punch 

Maruti Suzuki Ignis

Engine

1.2-litre three-cylinder

1.2-litre four-cylinder

Power (PS)

86PS 

83PS

Torque (Nm)

113Nm

113Nm

Transmission Options

5-speed manual / 5-speed AMT

5-speed manual / 5-speed AMT

Kerb Weight 

1,035kg

865kg 

ZW-Tata-Punch

The Tata has slightly better power figures, but it is heavier than the Ignis by 170kg. How does that affect the Tata when it comes to acceleration? 

Here’s what our VBOX says:

Note: Figures are for the BS4 Maruti Ignis. 

 

Tata Punch AMT

Maruti Suzuki Ignis AMT

DIfference

0-100kmph 

18.23 seconds

13.69 seconds 

4.54 seconds

20-80kmph (Kickdown)

11.97 seconds

8.21 seconds 

3.76 seconds 

ZW-Maruti-Suzuki-Ignis

Due to the Punch's laidback powertrain and more weight, it was a full 4.54 seconds behind the Ignis in the 0-100kmph run. The engine simply doesn't have the low-end response to get it going, unlike the Ignis' more responsive engine and quick-shifting AMT.  

ZW-Tata-Punch

This can also be seen in the 20-80kmph run, where the Tata is slower than the Maruti by 3.76 seconds. And it is this that makes the Maruti a more convenient drive within the city. 

That out of the way, let's find out which is the more frugal in the city and on the highway.  

 

Tata Punch AMT

Maruti Suzuki Ignis AMT

City

14.42kmpl

14.65kmpl

Highway

15.89kmpl

21.89kmpl

ZW-Tata-Punch

In town, the fuel efficiency figures of both models are almost similar. However, on the open road, the Ignis’ lighter weight and better-tuned AMT help it to deliver around 6kmpl more than the Tata. In our road test, we found that the Punch hesitates a bit to downshift in gradients and often tries to pull on in a higher gear, resulting in increased fuel consumption. 

 

Tata Punch 

Maruti Suzuki Ignis

Ex-showroom Price

Rs 5.49 lakh to Rs 9.39 lakh

Rs 5.1 lakh to Rs 7.47 lakh 

ZW-Maruti-Suzuki-Ignis

By now, it’s evident that the Ignis is quicker and more frugal than the Tata Punch. We will be pitting these two models against each other in an off-road test soon, so we hope you've subscribed to our YouTube channel already.

Tata Punch Video Review

More on Tata Punch

Tata Punch

Tata Punch

Rs. 5.64 Lakh Onwards
Ex-showroom, Delhi
View January Offer View On Road Price

See what our community has to say! NEW

India's largest automotive community

Explore Now
comminity image

4 Offers Available