Tata Punch EV vs Nexon EV: Which Tata Electric SUV Is Quicker And Offers Better Range?

In the latest edition of Zig performance comparison report, we have lined up the Tata Punch EV and Tata Nexon EV. The job for this report is simple - find out which Tata electric SUV offers better performance and range in the real-world. So without further ado, let’s get cracking. 

Spec Check 

Before we get to the acceleration figures, here’s a quick look at the specifications both the cars come packing with. For this test, we have brought the Long Range variants of both models. 

On paper, it’s the Nexon EV that is the more powerful out of the two. It also has the larger battery here, helping it eke out more range as well. But can the additional power help the Nexon EV win the acceleration test? 

Let’s find out. 

Acceleration Test 

Note: Acceleration for both cars tested in Sport mode

Whoa! This was super close to the line. The Nexon EV, with its power advantage, is the quicker car here in our flatout acceleration test to 100 kmph. But a more clearer way to look at real-world performance is in the roll-on acceleration test, where the Punch EV was the quicker one out of the two. 

Therefore, in the confines of this particular section, since both cars have scored an equal point, it makes sense to call it a draw. But which one manages to take the trophy in the range test? 

Let’s find out. 

Range Test 

To keep things fair in the range test, we decided to test out both the cars like how you would drive the car in regular conditions instead of hypermiling. So we set both EVs in Eco mode, re-gen on level 3, seat ventilation and AC set to 22 degrees. And after a day of driving, here’s how much kilometres we racked up after draining out the battery:

The Tata Nexon EV, with its bigger battery pack, managed to beat the Punch EV in the real-world range test by a fair margin. Also, note that both these models were tested on really hot conditions and they would have performed better in cooler weather. 

Price And Verdict 

Considering that the performance test is a draw and the Nexon EV managed to go a bit further with its larger battery pack, it wins this test. That being said, the performance and range offered by the Punch EV is commendable and you won’t go wrong with either of these two cars. If you want to know our impressions of the Tata Nexon EV, you can check out our first drive review. And if you had your eyes set on the Punch EV, check out its first drive review here.