MG Astor vs Tata Punch EV

MG Astor Price starts at Rs. 9.99 Lakh which is Rs. 800 costlier than base model of Tata Punch EV priced at Rs. 9.99 Lakh. The claimed mileage of MG Astor (Petrol Model) is 14.82 Kmpl . In technical specifications, MG Astor (Top Model) is powered by 1498 cc engine. The Comparison MG Astor Savvy Pro Sangria Turbo AT vs Tata Punch EV Empowered Plus S LR AC FC can be described on the basis of price and specifications.

Astor vs Punch EV

Key Highlights Astor Savvy Pro Sangria Turbo ATPunch EV Empowered Plus S LR AC FC
Engine Type 220TURBO ...
Motor Power ... 90 kW
Max Power 138.08bhp@5600rpm 120.69bhp
Range ... 421 km/charge
Charging Time ... 56 Min-50 kW(10-80%)
Mileage (ARAI) 14.34 Kmpl ...

Astor vs Punch EV Key Highlights

Basic Info MG Motor Astor Savvy Pro Sangria Turbo ATTata Punch EV Empowered Plus S LR AC FC
Rating
104 reviews
37 reviews
Brand Name MG Motor Tata
Ex-Showroom Price Rs. 18.34 Lakh Get On-Road Price Rs. 14.29 Lakh Get On-Road Price
Engine Displacement 1349 cc ...
Body Type SUVAll SUV Cars SUVAll SUV Cars
Max Power 138.08bhp@5600rpm 120.69bhp
No Of Cylinders 3 ...
Transmission Automatic Automatic
Gearbox 6-Speed AT Single Speed
Drive Type FWD FWD
Colors
MG Motor Astor Colors
Tata Punch EV Colors
Fuel Type Petrol Electric(Battery)
Mileage (ARAI) 14.34 Kmpl ...
Tyre Size 215/55 R17 195/60R16
Boot Space ... 366 Liters
Steering Mounted Audio Control Yes Yes
Cruise Control Yes Yes
Airbags Driver, Passenger and Side Front Driver, Passenger and Side Front
EMI
Rs. 35,493 @ 10.5% (60 months)
Rs. 27,643 @ 10.5% (60 months)
Servicing Cost
Rs. 21,411 / 5 years
...
Insurance Rs. 80,280 Astor Insurance Rs. 61,989 Punch EV Insurance
Brochure
Download Brochure
Download Brochure

Engine Type
220TURBO
...
Motor Power
...
90 kW
Engine Displacement
1349 cc
...
Battery Capacity
...
35 kWh
Motor Type
...
Permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM)
Max Power
138.08bhp@5600rpm
120.69bhp
Range
...
421 km/charge
Max Torque
220Nm@3600rpm
190Nm
Emission Norm Compliance
BS VI 2.0
ZEV
No Of Cylinders
3
...
Transmission
Automatic
Automatic
Gearbox
6-Speed AT
Single Speed
Valves Per Cylinder
4
Drive Type
FWD
FWD
Turbo Charger
...
Regenerative Braking
...
Regenerative Braking Levels
...
4
Drive Mode Types
...
ECO | CITY | SPORT
Mild Hybrid
...
Charging Time
...
56 Min-50 kW(10-80%)
Fast Charging
...
Charging Port
...
CCS-II
Charging Time (A.C)
...
5H 7.2 kW (10-100%)
Charging Time (D.C)
...
56 Min-50 kW(10-80%)

Fuel Type
Petrol
Electric(Battery)
0-100 kmph
...
9.5 Sec
Fuel Capacity
45 Liters
...
Mileage (ARAI)
14.34 Kmpl
...

Suspension Front
Suspension Rear
6
6
Brakes Front
Disc
Disc
Brakes Rear
Disc
Disc
Steering Type
Electric
Electric
Minimum Turning Radius
...
4.9 m
Tyre Size
215/55 R17
195/60R16
Wheel Size
...
Tyre Type
Radial Tubeless
Low rolling resistance

Ventilated Seats
Additional Interior Features
Interior Theme- Dual Tone Iconic Ivory(Optional), Dual Tone Sangria Red,Perforated Leather,Premium Leather# Layering on Dashboard, Door Trim,Door Armrest and Centre Console with Stitching Details,Premium Soft Touch Dashboard,Satin Chrome Highlights to Door Handles, Air Vents and Steering Wheel,Brit Dynamic Emblem on Dashboard,Interior Reading Lamp LED (Front&Rear), Leatherette Driver Armrest With Storage, PM 2.5 Filter, Seat Back Pockets, Rear Seat Middle Headrest, Rear Parcel Shelf
Smart Digital DRLs & Steering Wheel, Phygital Control panel, Auto Dimming IRVM, Leatherette Wrapped Steering wheel, Mood Lights, Jeweled Control knob
Rear Seat Headrest
...
Digital Cluster
Air Conditioner
Digital Odometer
Seating Capacity
5
5
Doors
5
5
Boot Space
...
366 Liters

Alloy Wheels
Additional Exterior Features
Full LED Hawkeye Headlamps with Black Highlights,Bold Celestial Grille,Chrome Finish On Window Beltline,Outside Door Handle with Chrome Highlights,Rear Bumper with Chrome Accentuated Dual Exhaust Design,Satin Silver Finish Roof Rails,Wheel & Side Cladding-Black,Front & Rear Bumper Skid Plate - Glossy Black Finish,Door Garnish - Glossy Black Finish,Sporty Black ORVM,High-Gloss Finish Fog Light Surround
Low Rolling Resistance Tires, Sequential Front Side Indicators, Diamond Cut Alloys
Rain Sensing Wiper
Trunk Light
...
Rear Spoiler
...
Roof Rails
Length*Width*Height
4323*1809*1650 mm3
3857*1742*1633 mm3
Wheelbase
2585 mm
2445 mm
Ground Clearance (Unladen)
...
190 mm

Connectivity
Android Auto, Apple CarPlay
Android Auto, Apple CarPlay
Addtional Comfort Features
Remote AC On/Off & Temperature Setting,Intelligent Headlamp Control
Customizable Single Pedal Drive, Portable Charging Cable, ZConnect, Paddle Shifter to Control Regen Modes, Front Armrest, Air Purifier With AQI Display, Smart Charging Indicator, Arcade.ev App Suite, Navigation in Cockpit (Driver View Maps)
USB Charger
Front & Rear
Front
Gear Shift Indicator
...
Rear Curtain
...
Not Available
Luggage Hook and Net
...
Battery Saver
...
Additional Entertainment Features
i-SMART 2.0 with Advanced UI,Head Turner: Smart Movement in Direction of Voice Interactive Emojis Including Greetings, Festival Wishes and Jokes,Head Turner: Smart Movement in Direction of Voice Interactive Emojis,JIO Voice Recognition with advanced Voice commands for Weather, Cricket,Calculator, Clock, Date/Day, Horoscope, Dictionary, News & Knowledge Including Greetings, Festival Wishes and Jokes,Jio Voice Recognition in Hindi,Enhanced Chit-Chat Interaction,Voice Commands Support to Control Skyroof, AC, Music, FM, Calling & More,Advanced UI with Widget customization of homescreen with multiple Homepages,Digital Key With Key Sharing Function,Customisable Lockscreen Wallpaper,Birthday Wish on Headunit (with customisable date option),Headunit Theme Store with Downloadable Themes,Preloaded Greeting Message On Entry (with customised message option)
HD Infotainment by HARMAN, Wireless Android Auto And Apple CarPlay, Multiple Voice Assistants(Hay Tata, Alexa, Siri, Google Assistant)
Smart Entry
...
Automatic Climate Control
Available
Available
Massage Seats
...
Not Available
Memory Functions For Seat
...
Not Available
One Touch Operating Power Windows
Driver's Window
...
Drive Modes
...
3
No of Speakers
6
4
AC
Rear AC Ducts
...
Heater
Power Steering
Steering Column
Tilt
...
Steering Mounted Audio Control
Cruise Control
Power Windows ( Front / Rear )
Front and Rear
Front and Rear
Adjustable Driver Seat
Heated Seat Front
Heated Seats Rear
Wireless Phone Charging
Subwoofer
Folding Rear Seat
60:40 Split
...
Height Adjustable Driver Seat
Engine Start Stop Button
Rear ACVents
...
Multifunction Steering Wheel
Air Quality Control
Tachometer
...
Hands Free Tailgate
...
Rear Seat Centre Arm Rest
Memory Function Seats
...
Not Available
Rear Windscreen Sunblind
...
Adjustable Headrest
Voice assisted sunroof
Seat Belt Warning
Push Ignition
AM/FM Radio
Touch-screen Display
Speakers Front
Speakers Rear
Auto Rain Sensing Wipers
Follow me home headlamps
Adjustable Headlamps
...
Parking Sensors
Rear
Rear
Front Cupholders
Door Pockets
Front & Rear Door
Front & Rear Door
12V Power Outlets
Cigarette Lighter
...
Bottle Holder
Front & Rear Door
Front & Rear Door
Sunroof
Panoramic
Single Pane

Anti-Pinch Power Windows
...
Speed Sensing Auto Door Lock
ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts
Day/Night Rearview Mirror
Blind Spot Monitor
Hill Descent Control
Hill Assist
Impact Sensing Auto Door Unlock
360 View Camera
Airbags
Driver, Passenger and Side Front
Driver, Passenger and Side Front
Anti-lock Braking System (ABS)
No of Airbags
6
6
Traction Control System (TCS)
...
Engine Immobilizer
...
Central Locking
Advance Safety Features
Red Brake Callipers - Front,Anti-Theft Immobilisation,Find My Car & Route to it,Smart Drive Information,Vehicle speeding Alert With Customisable Speed Limit,Critical Tyre Pressure Voice Alert,, Active Cornering Brake Control, Emergency Stop Signal, Emergency Fuel Cutoff, Ultra-High Tensile Steel Cage Body, Intrusion Minimizing and Collapsible Steering Column, Dual Horn, Auto dimming IRVM, Electric Parking Brake with Autohold,3 Point Seatbelts for All Passengers
Liquid Cooled Thermal Management System, IP67 Ingress Protection For Motor & Battery Pack, Auto Defogger, Electronic parking Brake with Autohold
Child Safety Lock
...
Rear Wash Wiper
Keyless Entry
Rear Defogger
Rear Camera
3
3

Automatic Emergency Braking
Forward Collision Warning
Blind Spot Collision Avoidance Assist
Lane Departure Warning
Lane Keep Assist
Driver Attention Warning
...
Leading Vehicle Departure Alert
...
Adaptive High Beam Assist
Oncoming Lane Mitigation
...
Speed Assist System
Traffic Sign Recognition
...
Lane Departure Prevention Assist
Road Depature Mitigation System
...
Adaptive Cruise Control
Rear Cross Traffic Alert
Rear Cross Traffic Collision Avoidance Assist
...

Over the Air (OTA) Updates
...
Google / Alexa Connectivity
...
Smartwatch App
Live Location
...
Remote Immobiliser
...
Engine Start Alarm
...
Remote Vehicle Status Check
...
Digital Car Key
...
Inbuilt Assistant
...
Hinglish Voice Commands
...
Navigation With Live Traffic
...
ECall And ICall
...
Over Speeding Alert
...
In Car Remote Control App
...
Remote Ac On Off
...
Remote Door Lock Unlock
...

Pros and Cons

  • Positives
  • Negatives
MG Astor
  • Simple yet attractive design
  • comfortable seating for four
  • sets a new benchmark in terms of cabin quality
  • punchy turbo petrol engine
  • ADAS adds a layer of safety and convenience.
Tata Punch EV
  • Feature loaded
  • great looks
  • multiple range options
  • easy and fun to drive with a comfortable ride
MG Astor
  • Narrow cabin makes it strictly a four-seater
  • boot space seems lesser than the competition
  • some feel-good features like ventilated seats are missing.
Tata Punch EV
  • Rear seats aren't spacious and boot space is limited
  • a bit pricey for its size and practicality

Is MG Astor Better Than Tata Punch EV?

60% users have chosen MG Astor over Tata Punch EV in a survey being conducted on zigwheels.com.
Apart from this survey a total of 219 users have also rated MG Astor and Tata Punch EV on some really important factors like Mileage , performance, comfort, safety etc. and have given their personal opinions about these cars.
As per the users experiences MG Astor is a winner for you if you are seriously looking for maintenance in your car. But Tata Punch EV is better on the grounds of mileage, performance and safety. On the basis of comfort and features user have rated both the cars equally.

Before making your decision you should also consider the unbiased and thorough analysis of these cars on every aspect by our auto experts who have summarised the analysis in pros, cons and final conclusion..

Ratings Factor Punch EV Astor
Mileage 3.2 4.2
Performance 3.9 4.2
Comfort 4.5 4.5
Maintenance 3.9 3.8
Safety 4.4 4.7
Features 4.5 4.5
Image
Do you own a Car or a Bike?
  • Interact with community
  • Become a Top Contributor
Add Car Add Bike

MG Astor Comparison with Similar Cars

Tata Punch EV Comparison with Similar Cars

Recently Asked User Questions

Q. Is tata punch EV is better then tata curvv ?
  • The Tata Punch EV and Tata Curvv EV serve different market segments, with each offering distinct advantages. The Punch EV is a compact, budget-friendly electric SUV designed primarily for city driving, offering practicality, affordability, and a range suitable for short urban commutes (around 250-300 km). It has a more basic set of features, with a focus on value for money. On the other hand, the Curvv EV is a more premium and larger SUV with a futuristic coupe-style design, intended for customers seeking higher performance, better range (likely 350-400 km), and advanced features. It offers more powerful performance, a more spacious interior, and luxurious tech, including advanced driver assistance systems and a larger infotainment setup. While the Punch EV is better for budget-conscious urban buyers, the Curvv EV targets those looking for a more stylish, feature-rich, and versatile electric vehicle.
Q. Which car to buy, Astor or Slavia?
Q. Which car is better Astor or S-Cross?
  • Both the cars are good in their forte. MG Astor is a well-balanced, compact SUV with a good mix of design, quality, performance, and safety. A solid contender in the segment. On the other hand, The S-Cross is a very capable city car. With a petrol engine, it will become even better in its city duties. However, the price will be a big deciding factor. For a better understanding of compatibility and driving comfort, we would suggest you to take a test drive. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealership..Read more -MG Astor First Drive Review: Standing Out In Style.

MG Motor Astor Vs Tata Punch EV FAQs

Which car is best between MG Motor Astor vs Tata Punch EV?
As per the users experiences MG Astor is a winner for you if you are seriously looking for maintenance in your car. But Tata Punch EV is better on the grounds of mileage, performance and safety. On the basis of comfort and features user have rated both the cars equally.
Which car is cheaper MG Motor Astor vs Tata Punch EV?
The Tata Punch EV is cheaper than MG Astor by Rs. 4.05 Lakh.
Which car offers better performance MG Motor Astor vs Tata Punch EV?
As per the users experiences the MG Astor has better performance.

Images of MG Astor and Tata Punch EV

×
Select Category