Mahindra Scorpio vs Mahindra Thar
Mahindra Scorpio vs Mahindra Thar Summary
Basic Info | Scorpio S11 | Thar LX 4-Str Hard Top Diesel AT |
---|---|---|
Brand Name | Mahindra | Mahindra |
Ex-Showroom Price | Rs. 18.62 Lakh View On Road Price | Rs. 16.03 Lakh View On Road Price |
Rating | 4.0 (2033 Ratings) |
4.3 (225 Ratings) |
Engine Displacement | 2179 cc | 2184 cc |
Body Type | SUVAll SUV Cars | SUVAll SUV Cars |
Fuel Type | Diesel | Diesel |
Max Power | 136.78bhp@3750rpm | 130bhp@3750rpm |
No Of Cylinders | 4 | 4 |
Transmission | Manual | Automatic |
Gear Box | 6 Speed | 6 Speed |
Drive Type | ... | 4X4 |
Colors | ||
Tyre Size | 235/65 R17 | 255/65 R18 |
Steering Mounted Audio Control | Yes | Yes |
Cruise Control | Yes | Yes |
Airbags | Driver and Passenger | Driver and Passenger |
Insurance | Rs. 99,952 Scorpio Insurance | Rs. 1.01 Lakh Thar Insurance |
Engine |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Performance |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Suspension |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Interior |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Exterior |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Comfort |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Safety |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Warranty |
|
Pros and Cons
- Positives
- Negatives
Mahindra Scorpio
- Proper SUV styling
- lots of space
- sturdy and durable
- comfortable ride quality
Mahindra Thar
- Looks modern with tweaked styling and improved interiors. Drivetrain includes petrol
- diesel and automatic options. 4x4 is standard. Washable interiors are a nice touch.
Mahindra Scorpio
- Ergonomics
- practical storage in the cabin
- new-age features
Mahindra Thar
- Mechanical rear locking differential only on the AX (Adventure) trim.
Is Mahindra Thar Better Than Mahindra Scorpio?
58% users have chosen Mahindra Thar over Mahindra Scorpio in a survey being conducted on zigwheels.com.
Apart from this survey a total of 2805 users have also rated Mahindra Thar and Mahindra Scorpio on some really important factors like Mileage , performance, comfort, safety etc. and have given their personal opinions about these cars.
As per the users experiences Mahindra Thar is a winner for you if you are seriously looking for performance, comfort, maintenance, safety and features in your car. On the basis of mileage user have rated both the cars equally.
Before making your decision you should also consider the unbiased and thorough analysis of these cars on every aspect by our auto experts who have summarised the analysis in pros, cons and final conclusion..
Ratings Factor | Thar | Scorpio |
---|---|---|
Mileage | 3.9 | 3.9 |
Performance | 4.6 | 4.4 |
Comfort | 4.2 | 4.0 |
Maintenance | 4.0 | 3.8 |
Safety | 4.3 | 3.9 |
Features | 4.5 | 4.1 |
Scorpio and Thar Competitors
-
Mahindra XUV700
Rs. 13.18 Lakh -
Kia Seltos
Rs. 10.19 Lakh -
Toyota Fortuner
Rs. 31.79 Lakh -
Mahindra Scorpio-N
Rs. 11.99 Lakh -
Tata Safari
Rs. 15.24 Lakh
News Updates on Scorpio and Thar
-
Mahindra Scorpio Classic: Variants And Engine Specifications Revealed24 Jun, 2022 | By Team ZigWheels
-
Cost Savings Hit Mahindra Thar In Latest Update21 Jun, 2022 | By Team ZigWheels
-
Upcoming Mahindra Scorpio Classic Sheds A Bit More Camo21 Jun, 2022 | By Team ZigWheels
-
The Mahindra Thar Gets Dearer For The Second Time In 202219 Apr, 2022 | By Team ZigWheels
-
Our Favourite Old Scorpio Ads Which Hilariously Exaggerate Mahindra’s “Nothing Else Will Do” Tag Line11 Jun, 2022 | By Team ZigWheels
-
Pratap Bose’s Christmas Themed Mahindra Thar Render Hints At Minor Tweaks We Wish Were On The Real Thing23 Dec, 2021 | By Team ZigWheels
-
To Look Fresh, Mahindra’s Scorpio Classic Will Take Inspiration From Successor3 Jun, 2022 | By Team ZigWheels
-
Mahindra Thar Registers 75,000 Bookings Since Launch5 Oct, 2021 | By Team ZigWheels
-
New Spy Shots Show Familiar Face On The Upcoming Mahindra Scorpio Classic28 May, 2022 | By Team ZigWheels
-
The Thar Gets Its Biggest Price Hike Since October 2020 Launch8 Jul, 2021 | By Team ZigWheels
Recently Asked User Questions
- Scorpio feels expensive for what it offers. S11 is top end variant at 19 lakhs on road price. S5 is the lowest variant with very basic interior with basic door panels like how omni has. It's on road price is 12-13 lakhs.Also there's a difference in their engine specs. If you need power not worried about mileage then go for s11 or else buy s5 or s7.Also mahindra is going to launch next generation Scorpio in 2021. Google it's pic.
- Scorpio has been the undisputed King of Indian roads for the last 16 years. It enjoys the confidence of more than 6.5 lakhs proud customers and continues to do well in a highly competitive landscape. One of the key aspects of Scorpio’s success has been its constant evolution to remain a great value proposition while retaining its core of Power, Driving Thrill and Adventure. With this said it would depend on how much you are looking to invest along with your preference in the features attached within respective variants.
- Scorpio has been the undisputed King of Indian roads for the last 16 years. It enjoys the confidence of more than 6.5 lakhs proud customers and continues to do well in a highly competitive landscape. Scorpio S9 comes with top-end features like Fully Automatic Temperature Control (FATC), 15 cm Touchscreen Infotainment with GPS navigation, Static-bending Projector Headlamps, LED Light Guides, ORVMs with Side-turn Indicators, Audio & Cruise Controls on Steering. Visit MAHINDRA SYOUV website https://www.mahindrasyouv.com/models/mahindra-scorpio for details.
- India ki koi bhi aisi car hamare engineer ne abhi tak to nahi banai jo rough road me use kare to hile nhi ya thodi si jump na kare mere samajh se to ye much luxurious hai.
- Scorpio is a luxurious but not much luxurious car comparing to other car but it is unique in under this price point . Bold SUV with some unique designs
- In its price segment it is a luxurious suv next to XUV 500 . Both of the suv prices are more or less same in which XUV 500 is more luxurious.
- There is no difference between S10 and S11. Though S10 used to be the top variant before 2019 now S11 is the top variant of the Scorpio.They both have similar engine and configuration etc...
- Will it be a good idea if I still own an S10?
- Will it be a good idea if I still own an S10?
Scorpio Vs Thar Comparison FAQs
Mahindra Thar is better on the grounds of performance, comfort, maintenance, safety and features. On the basis of mileage user have rated both the cars equally.
The Mahindra Thar is cheaper than Mahindra Scorpio by Rs. 2.59 Lakh.
For the S11 version, 2179 cc Diesel engine of Scorpio produces 136.78bhp@3750rpm of power and 319Nm@1800-2800rpm of torque. Whereas for the LX 4-Str Hard Top Diesel AT version, 2184 cc Diesel engine of Thar produces 130bhp@3750rpm of power and 300nm@1600-2800rpm of torqueAs per the users experiences the Mahindra Scorpio has better performance.
User Reviews of Comparison
- Mahindra Scorpio
- Mahindra Thar
-
I have been using Scorpio for many years. First, I bought, A Scorpio S10 and I am using it in Arunachal Pradesh. Here road condition is dangerous and muddy. I drove s10 at the speed of 170 km/hr and the whole maintenance cost from 2015 to now is under 4 lakh which is extremely affordable. After using s10, I was satisfied. Therefore, I bought Scorpio again now this time s11, Having 140 bhp with good mileage it browned my mind. The performance of the s11 is outrageous, I drove this car whole Himalayas range from Ladakh, Spiti, Whole Himachal and Uttarakhand, Some cities of Punjab, Up, Haryana and Rajasthan. From 2019 to 2021, I lived in Delhi, Therefore these all places are my weekend visit niche. Thus, My s11 serviced all service centres of North India and all records are present on my booklet and the service charge is pocket friendly. After mid-2021, I have visited the whole of Sikkim, Darjeeling, Kalimpong, Nepal, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland, Assam, Later back to Arunachal again now I am residing in Arunachal Pradesh again. In my opinion, Scorpio is the best-rugged vehicle for rough, Hilly and 4×4 roads, However, Scorpio doesn't need 4*4 to go all these areas and I have proof to support my verdict, You can check my Instagram and youtube feed by going to my profile "header stang", You would love the strength of Scorpio. For instance, In January I visited Tawang. There was heavy snowfall happening, At that time all vehicles were struggling to ascent the hill but Scorpio easily ascent up the Bum La Pass. It was struggling at y-junction and the driver step back to the hotel because Thar all wheels were spinning, but not moving ahead from that position for 1.5 hours. I will suggest to all buyers there, Scorpio is one of the best SUVs for our Indian rough road and its maintenance cost is way cheaper than under 7 lakh cars. I have Maruti and Toyota's SUV but their maintenance cost is not pocket friendly. Moreover, in my opinion. Scorpio is the beast among all the SUVs because it is ready to go all-terrain, and the cost of this vehicle is cheaper than its competitors. If you want to go to the snow area, you just use a snow chain only, because of black ice and you don't need any 4*4 for black ice. All SUVs need snow chains. Otherwise, wheels only spin and won't go anywhere. Therefore, Scorpio is the best vehicle for Indian roads and it is ensured, You will get beast in a small amount.
Mountain Lover 1 week ago -
The car I own is a 2.2 mHawk VLX Scorpio Makes 124HP and 290NM of Torque the highlight is that it"s an AT 6-Speed Borg Warner AT gearbox city Fuel economy 11KMPL highway fuel economy is 14KMPL and can be pushed up to 18 with Economic and conservative driving Adequate comfort and ample space Being a 7 seater the the last row isn"t meant for any person above 5"4 Love the audio Quality from the Stock Audio system which also has Bluetooth connectivity and a Mic for calls (Mahindra Radio)however I got a couple of Tweeters and speakers for an even better experienceThe top speed I reached is 176KMH while 0-100 takes 14s considering the fact that it"s a pretty Heavy AT SUV the timings impressiveIt feels even quicker while driving it It"s height is both a con and a pro as it"s height gives you that commanding feel and Safe over bumps potholes even with all 7 in place the height makes it a mission for older people to get in and get out The suspension is on the softer side Good over bumps but sometimes the ride feels on the Jerkier side (only in City)
JNithish Fdo few weeks ago -
Scorpio’s bold SUV styling, distinct road presence and all-terrain capability make it one of the most iconic SUVs of the countryExperience thrill like never-before with the New Scorpio in its most powerful avatar, with 140 hp Power and 320 Nm TorqueIts enhanced low-end torque ensures a pleasurable city drive & abundant mid-range torque delivers a pleasurable highway drive, while the New 6th generation Turbo Charger makes the drive peppy and responsive all throughIts New easy shift 6-Speed Transmission allows you to optimize performance, cruise on the highways in overdrive and save fuelThe New All Powerful Scorpio looks even more imposing now with a New bold front grille, New muscular alloys, New skid plate and New ORVMs with integrated side turn indicators and chrome finished fog lamps. Its redesigned tail gate with New attractive red lens LED tail lamps add to its dominating presenceExperience new levels of comfort with New plush faux leather interiors, New leather wrapped steering wheel & gear lever. Its new refinements result in a quieter cabinIt offers technology features like the New reverse parking camera with dynamic assist, 6-inch Touchscreen Infotainment with GPS, fully automatic temperature control, projector headlamps with static bending technology and much moreIts New latest generation braking system with ABS9.1 Bosch Antilock Braking System offers enhanced high-speed braking and improved brake feelWith Scorpio’s commanding seating position, dominating road presence and abundant power, you will continue to feel like the King of the Road
Mahindra SYOUV few weeks ago -
Generation(s) ahead in terms of the very concept of a home grown suv made into production, And is a market leader which rule(s) and roar(s) like a lion, Steers like a falcon, And is agile, Fast and precise like a hawk.True to its name that evolve with an (r) to spell the revolve in vibrance of a scorpio being sensitive, Idealistic, Masculine and clairvoyant representing the power towards an never ending exalting relationship.Brilliant, Gifted with great strength of character, The scorpio is owner's pride and neighbour's envy.
Sabyasachi Dutt 2 weeks ago -
Scorpio is made to match the grueling roads of india and especially rural india.It is my family car for long and short rides in around my city.I have done 1, 98.760 km since i bought it.It helped me in my city's disaster time of terror bombings to reach the victims to hospitals.I worked for emergency management and research institute at hyderabad.It is more than value for money rather paisa vasool vehicle.
MV Rao few weeks ago
-
Sorry for misleading everyone, But it hasn't arrived yet here in australia.It is a substitute for a jeep, Which is insanely expensive here.
Barry Fitzhenry few weeks ago -
Very good car, And he also has 4×4 option, And i like this car very much, You people can test drive the car and you also loved it
Nikhil Raj 2 weeks ago -
It's a best vehicle to use for farm and for house use and fully modified Mahindra that crde and in back it also as hook
Basvaraj K few weeks ago -
20 kilometres awarj dena saye tha jada log late thai gadi bot asi hai masat batiful gagi hai salaneme bot maja ata hai
MS RATHORE few weeks ago -
I like thar. My dream car is thar. Thar is the best car for offering. Black color of thar is look like very legend.
Lakhminarayan Saikia few weeks ago
Images of Mahindra Scorpio,Mahindra Thar
Popular Cars Comparison
- Trending
- SUV
- Hatchback
- Sedan
- Luxury
-
Start a new comparison
-
Start a new comparison
-
Start a new comparison
-
Start a new comparison