Mahindra Scorpio vs Mahindra Thar Comparison
Mahindra Scorpio vs Mahindra Thar
Mahindra Scorpio S3 Price starts at Rs. 10.20 lakh which is Rs. 60,134 costlier than Mahindra Thar CRDe priced at Rs. 9.60 lakh. The claimed mileage for the Mahindra Scorpio Diesel is 15.4 kmpl where as claimed mileage for Mahindra Thar Diesel is 16.6 kmpl. In technical specifications, Mahindra Scorpio S3 is powered by 2523 cc engine where as Mahindra Thar CRDe is powered by 2498 cc engine. 65% users have chosen Mahindra Thar over Mahindra Scorpio in a survey being conducted on zigwheels.com. Compare Mahindra Scorpio vs Mahindra Thar on the basis of price, specifications & other features.
Scorpio vs Thar Specs Overview
| Specs/Features | Scorpio S11 4WD | Thar 700 CRDe ABS |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Rs. 16.83 lakh | Rs. 9.99 lakh |
| Engine Displacement | 2179 cc | 2498 cc |
| Fuel Type | Diesel | Diesel |
| Power | 140bhp@3750rpm | 105bhp@3800rpm |
| No Of Cylinders | 4 | 4 |
| Transmission | Manual | Manual |
| Gear Box | 6 Speed | 5 Speed |
| Drive Type | 4WD | 4WD |
| Mileage (ARAI) kmpl | 16.36 kmpl | 16.55 kmpl |
| Tyre Size | 235/65 R17 | 235/70 R16 |
| Boot Space | 460 | ... |
| Length Width Height | 4456*1820*1995 | 3920*1726*1930 |
| Steering Mounted Audio Control | Yes | No |
| Cruise Control | Yes | No |
| Airbags | Driver and Passenger | Driver |
Engine
| Engine Type | mHawk Diesel Engine | NEF TCI-CRDe Engine |
| Engine Displacement | 2179 cc | 2498 cc |
| Fuel Type | Diesel | Diesel |
| Power | 140bhp@3750rpm | 105bhp@3800rpm |
| Torque | 320Nm@1500-2800rpm | 247Nm@1800-2000rpm |
| No Of Cylinders | 4 | 4 |
| Transmission | Manual | Manual |
| Gear Box | 6 Speed | 5 Speed |
| Drive Type | 4WD | 4WD |
| Paddle Shift |
Performance
| 0-100 kmph (sec) | 11.68 Seconds | ... |
| 30-70 kmph (3rd gear) | 6.75 Seconds | ... |
| 40-80 kmph (4th gear) | 11.90 Seconds | ... |
| Braking (100-0 kmph) | 48.09m | ... |
| Braking (80-0 kmph) | 27.27m | ... |
| Mileage (ARAI) kmpl | 16.36 kmpl | 16.55 kmpl |
| Top Speed (Km/h) | 163 | 154 |
Suspension
| Suspension Front | Double Wish-bone Type | Independent Suspensio |
| Suspension Rear | Multi-Link | Semi Elliptical Leaf Spring |
| Brakes Front | Ventilated Disc | Disc |
| Brakes Rear | Drum | Drum |
| Steering Type | Power | Power |
| Minimum Turning Radius | 5.65 metres | 5.75 metres |
| Tyre Size | 235/65 R17 | 235/70 R16 |
| Wheel Size | ... | R16 |
| Alloy Wheel Size | 17 Inch | 16 Inch |
| Tyre Type | Tubeless,Radial | Tubeless |
Interior
| Dual Tone Dashboard | ||
| Ventilated Seats | ||
| Additional Interior Features | Puddle Lamp | 700 edition special badge letherette fornt seats, 5spoke alloy wheels comes in only, two colous special, bonet and side decals |
| Fabric Upholstery | ||
| Leather Seats | ||
| Rear Seat Headrest | ||
| Seating Capacity | 7 | 6 |
| Doors | 5 | 3 |
| Boot Space | 460 | ... |
| Fuel Capacity | 60 Liters | 60 Liters |
Exterior
| Alloy Wheels | ||
| Lighting | Projector Headlights,LED Tail lamps | ... |
| Trunk Opener | Lever | Lever |
| Additional Exterior Features | LED Eyebrows, Rear Footrest, Front And Rear Bumpers Body Coloured, Side Clading Body Coloured, ORVMs And Door Handles Body Coloured, Ski Rack, Front Fog Lamp With Chrome Bezel, Rear Number Plate Applique Chrome, Silver Skid Plate, Bonnet Scoop, Fender Bezel Silver Finish, Center High Mounted Stop Lamp LED, Tyer Tronics, Clear Lens Turn Indicators, Front Grille Inserts Chrome, Red Lens LED Tail Lamps, Aeroblade Rear Wiper | letherette fornt seats |
| Outside Rear View Mirror | ||
| Turn indicators on ORVM | ||
| Xenon Headlights | ||
| Trunk Light | ||
| Rear Spoiler | ||
| Antenna | ||
| Roof Rails | ||
| Length Width Height | 4456*1820*1995 | 3920*1726*1930 |
| Wheelbase | 2680mm | 2430mm |
| Ground Clearance (Unladen) | 180mm | 200mm |
Comfort
| In Car Entertainment (Audio) | Speakers & Tweeters, 15Cms Touch Screen Infotainment With Bluetooth/CD/DVD/USB/AUX | Provision For 2-Din Music System |
| Addtional Comfort Features | 8 seater Front facing Power Windows Switches On Door Trims, Roof Mounted Sunglass Holder, Rear Demister, Hydraulic Assisted Bonnet, Headlamp Levelling Switch, Foot Step Black, Mobile Pocket In Center Console, Shift On Fly 4WD Optional, Auto Roll Up Smart Driver Window, Extended Power Window, Hydraulic Power Steering, second row can holder on console | Door Trim With Armrest, Floor Console, |
| USB Charger | Front | Not Available |
| Central Control Armrest | Available | Not Available |
| Tailgate Ajar | ||
| Gear Shift Indicator | ||
| Rear Curtain | Not Available | Not Available |
| Luggage Hook and Net | ||
| Battery Saver | ||
| Lane Change Indicator | ||
| Additional Entertainment Features | 15 cm Infotainment, Tweeters | ... |
| Smart Entry | ||
| Massage Seats | Not Available | Not Available |
| Memory Functions For Seat | Not Available | Not Available |
| One Touch Operating Power Windows | Driver's Window | Not Available |
| Autonomous Parking | Not Available | Not Available |
| Drive Modes | ||
| Internal Storage | ||
| No of Speakers | 4 | ... |
| Rear Entertainment System | ||
| AC | ||
| Rear AC Ducts | ||
| Heater | ||
| Power Steering | ||
| Steering Column | Tilt | Recirculating-ball steering |
| Steering Mounted Audio Control | ||
| Cruise Control | ||
| Power Windows ( Front / Rear ) | Front and Rear | |
| Adjustable Driver Seat | ||
| Heated Seat Front | ||
| Heated Seats Rear | ||
| Adjustable Front Passenger Seat | ||
| Lumbar Support | ||
| Folding Rear Seat | Bench Folding | Bench Folding |
| Rear Seat Center Armrest | ||
| Tachometer | ||
| Dual Trip Meter | ||
| Low Fuel Warning Lamp | ||
| Clock | ||
| Seat Belt Warning | ||
| Push Ignition | ||
| AM/FM Radio | ||
| USB Auxiliary Input | ||
| DVD Playback | ||
| Touch-screen Display | ||
| GPS Navigation System | ||
| Speakers Front | ||
| Speakers Rear | ||
| Automatic Head Lamps | ||
| Auto Rain Sensing Wipers | ||
| Follow me home headlamps | ||
| Adjustable Head Lights | ||
| Parking Sensors | Rear | Rear |
| Remote Operated Fuel Tank Lid | ||
| Front Cupholders | ||
| Door Pockets | Front & Rear Door | Not Available |
| 12V Power Outlets | ||
| Cigarette Lighter | ||
| Bottle Holder | Front & Rear Door | Not Available |
| Sun Roof | ||
| Moon Roof |
Safety
| Speed Sensing Auto Door Lock | ||
| Knee Airbags | ||
| ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts | ||
| Head-Up Display | ||
| Day/Night Rearview Mirror | ||
| Blind Spot Monitor | ||
| Hill Descent Control | ||
| Hill Assist | ||
| Impact Sensing Auto Door Unlock | ||
| 360 View Camera | ||
| Airbags | Driver and Passenger | Driver |
| Seat Belts | ||
| Anti-lock Braking System (ABS) | ||
| Electronic Brakeforce Distribution (EBD) | ||
| Brake Assist (BA) | ||
| Electronic Stability Program (ESP) | ||
| Traction Control System (TCS) | ||
| Engine Immobilizer | ||
| Central Locking | ||
| Child Safety Lock | ||
| Fog Lamps (Front / Rear ) | Front | |
| Rear Wash Wiper | ||
| Rear Defogger |
Recently Asked User Questions
Q. Which model of Scorpio is the best?
- S5: It is in this variant that the Scorpio starts to make more sense. The more powerful engine, bigger wheels and more kit on-board sum up to a more meaningful package. The added safety, which is rapidly becoming a key area of attention is also addressed with two airbags and ABS. This variant is well suited for anyone who has always loved the big, brawny looks of the Scorpio, but is on a tight budget. Sure, it isn’t as feature loaded as it could be, but it does have almost all the basic features expected from a car of this size and price. S7: The S7 variant enhances the comfort and safety aspect, with a rear defogger, rear wiper with washer, anti-theft alert and the Intellipark technology which delivers visual and audio notifications while reverse parking into a slot. This variant is best suited for someone looking for an 8-seat layout, which is unavailable in the S3 and S5 variants. Moreover, at this price, the Scorpio comes with a handsome features package and comes with body-coloured panels. Moreover, the added ski rack on top of the roof comes in more than handy to transport oversized goods. S11: This S11 variant is the most feature-loaded of the lot. Apart from the additional seating configuration options, the S11 gets a 6.0-inch infotainment display, tyre pressure monitoring system, auto headlamps and wipers and a more premium upholstery inside. But, even at this price, the Scorpio misses out on features like electrically foldable ORVMs, no Android Auto or Apple CarPlay compatibility, sunroof, automatic transmission and more airbags. If you can do without these misses, but can’t with what the S11 gets over the S7, go for it. However, the price hike is a bit too steep and we’d recommend you to go for the S7 (140PS) and get whatever you need extra from an aftermarket shop. It’ll be more affordable that way.
- Scorpio has been the undisputed King of Indian roads for the last 16 years. It enjoys the confidence of more than 6.5 lakhs proud customers and continues to do well in a highly competitive landscape. One of the key aspects of Scorpio’s success has been its constant evolution to remain a great value proposition while retaining its core of Power, Driving Thrill and Adventure. With this said it would depend on how much you are looking to invest along with your preference in the features attached within respective variants.
- Scorpio has been the undisputed King of Indian roads for the last 16 years. It enjoys the confidence of more than 6.5 lakhs proud customers and continues to do well in a highly competitive landscape. Scorpio S9 comes with top-end features like Fully Automatic Temperature Control (FATC), 15 cm Touchscreen Infotainment with GPS navigation, Static-bending Projector Headlamps, LED Light Guides, ORVMs with Side-turn Indicators, Audio & Cruise Controls on Steering. Visit MAHINDRA SYOUV website https://www.mahindrasyouv.com/models/mahindra-scorpio for details.
Q. Which model of Thar is value for money?
- Close your eyes and go for crde 4x4. I have been driving thar for last 3 months and its been my primary vehicle. In city or highway or off road its the best. It carries the older scorpio engine and its refined and with customization from T8 or code 6 you can achieve upto 160 hp. After owning Honda city, figo 2015, endeavor 2017 and now thar. I say it's the best if you want to enjoy raw Power and the tough vehicle just go for thar. The attention that thar grabs no other vehicle grabs.
- Yes , As the THAR CRDe has yet again set new benchmarks with its bold muscular road presence, unmatched go anywhere capability, refined and power-packed performance that’s best in its category.
- If you are looking forward for comfort and ease which can be used by a family than Thar CRDe variant would be a good choice moreover if you are an enthusiast and wanted to use it specifically for off-roading than DI 4WD would be a preferred choice.
Q. Between scorpio and creta, which one is better?
- For highway sprints creta. If 5 seater is ok then creta. If you need 7 or 8 seater than scorpio is the only choice. However City driving is also a fun with scorpio's perfect gear ratios. Driving one for past 5 years no problems yet...
- I think only if you want to drive offroad than only scorpio is better else it cannot compete creta in terms of Comfort, smoothness, features, speed pickup and many more for eg I driven Creta at 190 speed , this is not even the top speed of scorpio
- Scorpio is full size SUV with seven seats and 4x4 system. Creta is small 5 siter suv with features and good performance
Top Hatchback Comparisons
Top SUV Comparisons
Top Sedan Comparisons
