-
Q. I was interested to buy a Harrier, but I am having 2nd opinion after enquiring about the SUV with a friend, who recently bought one and facing engine problems. He said the problem started (within 3 weeks!) with steering vibration which was resolved by dealer. The other issue is engine sound inside cabin. He said, that typical old diesel car knocking sound comes during pickup, (after gear shift). Can anyone please explain how a brand new premium SUV (built on Range Rover platform), the show-piece car of TATA Motors, can have such problems?
19.7K Views Follow Question Add Answer36 Answers
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago1 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago2 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago0 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Arnav | 4 years ago10 ReplySee, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Scale | 4 years ago4 ReplyNot sure when this was first posted. I got a Dark Edition Automatic. As far as drive experience is concerned car is very good. Car gets smooth at higher RPMs. Cabin noise issue minimized in BS6. A bit still filters thru but that's the diesel engine. I guess one has to live with it. Above 2000 rpm buttery smooth. No issues so far. Have clocked 4000 km on the car. Only issue I have is that yesterday the infotainment system didn't respond to increase or decrease in volume. A couple of restarts solved the issue.
Nelamalli | 4 years ago0 ReplyThis issue was there in 2019 models.. with 2020 and above models the issue has been resolved. I own a dark edition HT PLUS variant. I drive daily in city and occasionally on highways. There is no variation in performance. 2.0 engines have some noise which can't be avoided but that is not too loud. You don't even notice that in high speeds.
Rahul | 6 years ago4 Reply5k done Agreed on noisy cabin if someone is harsh on accelator pedal. But if someone is gentle it's more silent as other 2.0 diesel engines. Ride quality is buttery smooth no niggles yet. Mileage in city 13 to 14 kmpl and on highways above 18 kmpl. Routine updates from TML makes this car even more user friendly.
Vinayak | 6 years ago2 ReplyIt's been three months since Im driving the harrier and after driving around 7000kms here are the issues with the vehicle - engine noise is quite loud at lower rpms , clutch sounds when I shift gears, steering vibration and sounds of loose parts coming from the dash board which never happened in my earlier cars(vw polo/Honda city). Not quite a good experience for me so far. Needs more improvement . However the seating comfort is something other cars don't offer in this price segment
Kripa | 6 years ago0 Reply@ Vinayak | It's been three months since Im driving the harrier and after driving around 7000kms here are the issues with the vehicle - engine noise is quite loud at lower rpms , clutch sounds when I shift gears, steering vibration and sounds of loose parts coming from the dash board which never happened in my earlier cars(vw polo/Honda city). Not quite a good experience for me so far. Needs more improvement . However the seating comfort is something other cars don't offer in this price segment
Prevent wear and tear of cluch due to engine vibration . This clutch system have normal noise. You can Cheak it on YouTube.
Nishanth | 6 years ago4 ReplyI drove 8000kms. No engine issue till now. Cabin engine noise is a bit high, but only when you accelerate at around 100kmph in sports mode. Engine could have been tuned even finer. But that's a trade off we need to make for rest of the things about the car are wonderful. Adjusting seat to counter the blindspot on the right due to huge A pillar and huge ORVM is one more issue I found with the car.
Mukul | 4 years ago1 ReplyIts almost 2 months now. First there was issue in sunroof. Now its resolved. Since 2 days, I observed issue in central locking. Looks like wrong decision. Not impressed with Tata Motors quality and quality checks.
Amit | 5 years ago1 Reply@ Vinayak | Nope. After service updates from the company all issues have been resolved. Have driven 15000 kms now. No vibrations or clutch issues.
@viayak Initially i did not face any clutch issue however after service updates of clutch , the clutch has gone hard which was very smooth initially , do you fell the same ?
Sujit | 4 years ago0 ReplyTata motors are crap. Their high end vehicles have all failed so no idea why buyers don't do basic research. Go for a Tata only if the budget is below 7 Lacs.
Vinayak | 5 years ago0 Reply@ Sriharsha | Hey Vinayak, do you still face clutch sound during gear shifting
Nope. After service updates from the company all issues have been resolved. Have driven 15000 kms now. No vibrations or clutch issues.
Shashi | 6 years ago0 ReplyClutch got burnt out after 100 KMS of driving. Got repair under warranty with great difficulty. Manufacturing and design defects.
Kripa | 6 years ago0 Reply@ Vinayak | It's been three months since Im driving the harrier and after driving around 7000kms here are the issues with the vehicle - engine noise is quite loud at lower rpms , clutch sounds when I shift gears, steering vibration and sounds of loose parts coming from the dash board which never happened in my earlier cars(vw polo/Honda city). Not quite a good experience for me so far. Needs more improvement . However the seating comfort is something other cars don't offer in this price segment
Prevent wear and tear of cluch due to engine vibration . This clutch system have normal noise. You can Cheak it on YouTube.
Hitesh | 4 years ago0 Reply@ Mukul | Its almost 2 months now. First there was issue in sunroof. Now its resolved. Since 2 days, I observed issue in central locking. Looks like wrong decision. Not impressed with Tata Motors quality and quality checks.
I am planning to buy harrier but after your review now i am confused ! Any suggestions ? Now I am waiting for xuv 500 2021
Bitskits | 4 years ago0 ReplyNVH levels r little high in Harrier n this is not a engine problem. If you have driven Fortuner, you will get the same feeling.
Binod | 5 years ago1 ReplyDnt purchase Tata Harrier. M holding xz which got broke down twice in a single month because of the clutch issue.
Dev | 4 years ago0 Reply@ Scale | Not sure when this was first posted. I got a Dark Edition Automatic. As far as drive experience is concerned car is very good. Car gets smooth at higher RPMs. Cabin noise issue minimized in BS6. A bit still filters thru but that's the diesel engine. I guess one has to live with it. Above 2000 rpm buttery smooth. No issues so far. Have clocked 4000 km on the car. Only issue I have is that yesterday the infotainment system didn't respond to increase or decrease in volume. A couple of restarts solved the issue.
If you have to 'Live with' high NVH levels after spending 22L, It sure is not a good buy
Rahul | 4 years ago0 ReplyI have the 2020 Harrier Automatic XZA+ it’s absolutely stunning haven’t had any issues so far
Sriharsha | 5 years ago2 Reply@ Vinayak | It's been three months since Im driving the harrier and after driving around 7000kms here are the issues with the vehicle - engine noise is quite loud at lower rpms , clutch sounds when I shift gears, steering vibration and sounds of loose parts coming from the dash board which never happened in my earlier cars(vw polo/Honda city). Not quite a good experience for me so far. Needs more improvement . However the seating comfort is something other cars don't offer in this price segment
Hey Vinayak, do you still face clutch sound during gear shifting
Arun | 4 years ago1 ReplyDon't buy this car. I purchased XZA + and the car is making brake noise from day 1. The dealer syas that this noise is common in Tata Harrier cars.
Ayush | 4 years ago0 Reply@ Arnav | See, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Actually fiat sourced engine
Loumo | 3 years ago0 ReplyBetween harrier 2007 to 2009 is there any difference and which of the two is better
Vishnu | 5 years ago0 Reply@ Shashi | Clutch got burnt out after 100 KMS of driving. Got repair under warranty with great difficulty. Manufacturing and design defects.
Hi sir
Sharad | 4 years ago0 Reply@ Arnav | See, it's simple! Tata Motors didn't use an engine of their own in the Harrier. The used the FCA Source Jeep's 2.0 litre engine with 170bhp and 350Nm of power and torque respectively. But, in the Harrier, they detuned it to 149 bhp. Now, since it'd been long since they manufactured a big car, especially of an engine this big. For the SUV stance, they kept it raw-be it the gearbox, the clutch or even the insulation levels for that matter. But in the 2020 Harrier, all those issues have been addressed by Tata Motors, and the Harrier is now really a great car to buy...so go ahead and get it
Well explained. Cheers !!!
Shakti | 6 years ago3 ReplyI have already drove 3000km....no issue....
Add your Answer
Incorrect word(s) in your text, please rectify Submit Answer
Check What Experts Say
-
2020 Tata Harrier Automatic: First Drive ReviewMore power, an automatic transmission and some new features to top it all off. These updates come just a year after the Harrier was originally launched and there’s a big reason why!
-
Tata Harrier vs Hyundai Creta vs Jeep Compass: Comparison ReviewIs the Tata Harrier a sensible alternative to the Hyundai Creta? And does it do enough to drive you away from the Jeep Compass?
-
Tata Harrier: First Drive ReviewCan the Harrier pull off the premium tag and convince SUV buyers to go the Tata way?
Tata Harrier 2019-2023 Questions
900+ Answers from Experts & Owners
- Interact with community
- Become a Top Contributor
Thanks for reporting this. The reported answer will be shortly removed from Zigwheels &
will be sent for moderation.
- Home ›
- Tata Harrier 2019-2023 QnA ›
- I was interested to buy a Harrier, but I am having 2nd opinion...
Choose your city
-
New Delhi
-
Bengaluru
-
Mumbai
-
Kolkata
-
Chennai
-
Pune
-
Hyderabad
-
Ahmedabad
-
Patna
Thank you! Your question has been submitted and is under moderartion.
You will receive all communications on :
Say a Car or a Bike Name
Cancel
