New Car
Explore all New Cars of 2024
MG Astor vs Tata Punch
MG Astor Price starts at Rs. 9.99 Lakh which is Rs. 3.86 Lakh costlier than base model of Tata Punch priced at Rs. 6.12 Lakh. The claimed mileage of MG Astor (Petrol Model) is 14.82 Kmpl whereas claimed mileage of Tata Punch (Petrol Model) is 18.8 Kmpl. In technical specifications, MG Astor (Top Model) is powered by 1498 cc engine , while Tata Punch (Top Model) is powered by 1199 cc engine. The Comparison MG Astor Savvy Pro Sangria Turbo AT vs Tata Punch Creative Plus S Camo AMT can be described on the basis of price and specifications.
Astor vs Punch
| Key Highlights | Astor Savvy Pro Sangria Turbo AT | Punch Creative Plus S Camo AMT |
|---|---|---|
| Engine Type | 220TURBO | 1.2 l Revotron |
| Max Power | 138.08bhp@5600rpm | 87bhp@6000rpm |
| Mileage (ARAI) | 14.34 Kmpl | 18.8 Kmpl |
-
MG Motor Astor
Rs. 18.34 Lakh EMI - Rs. 35,493 View December OffersTata Punch
Rs. 10.14 Lakh EMI - Rs. 19,633 View December Offers
Astor vs Punch Key Highlights
| Basic Info | MG Motor Astor Savvy Pro Sangria Turbo AT | Tata Punch Creative Plus S Camo AMT |
|---|---|---|
| Rating |
104 reviews
|
287 reviews
|
| Brand Name | MG Motor | Tata |
| Ex-Showroom Price | Rs. 18.34 Lakh Get On-Road Price | Rs. 10.14 Lakh Get On-Road Price |
| Engine Displacement | 1349 cc | 1199 cc |
| Body Type | SUVAll SUV Cars | SUVAll SUV Cars |
| Max Power | 138.08bhp@5600rpm | 87bhp@6000rpm |
| No Of Cylinders | 3 | 3 |
| Transmission | Automatic | Automatic |
| Gearbox | 6-Speed AT | 5-Speed AMT |
| Drive Type | FWD | FWD |
| Colors | ||
| Fuel Type | Petrol | Petrol |
| Mileage (ARAI) | 14.34 Kmpl | 18.8 Kmpl |
| Tyre Size | 215/55 R17 | 195/60 R16 |
| Boot Space | ... | 366 Liters |
| Steering Mounted Audio Control | Yes | Yes |
| Cruise Control | Yes | Yes |
| Airbags | Driver, Passenger and Side Front | Driver and Passenger |
| EMI |
Rs. 35,493
@
10.5% (60 months)
|
Rs. 19,633
@
10.5% (60 months)
|
| Servicing Cost |
Rs. 21,411 / 5 years
|
Rs. 23,561 / 5 years
|
| Insurance | Rs. 80,280 Astor Insurance | Rs. 50,106 Punch Insurance |
| Brochure |
Download
Brochure
|
Download
Brochure
|
Engine |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Performance |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Suspension |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Interior |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Exterior |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Comfort |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Safety |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
ADAS Feature |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Advance Internet Feature |
|
Pros and Cons
- Positives
- Negatives
MG Astor
- Simple yet attractive design
- comfortable seating for four
- sets a new benchmark in terms of cabin quality
- punchy turbo petrol engine
- ADAS adds a layer of safety and convenience.
Tata Punch
- The Punch is a good mix of a hatchback and an SUV. Impressive cabin quality
- clever customization options make it even more appealing. New 10.25-inch touchscreen for 2024. Received a 5-star Global NCAP safety rating.
MG Astor
- Narrow cabin makes it strictly a four-seater
- boot space seems lesser than the competition
- some feel-good features like ventilated seats are missing.
Tata Punch
- No diesel engine option. The 1.2L engine lacks the punch for ease of use on highway or when fully loaded.
Is MG Astor Better Than Tata Punch?
54% users have chosen MG Astor over Tata Punch in a survey being conducted on zigwheels.com.
Apart from this survey a total of 741 users have also rated MG Astor and Tata Punch on some really important factors like Mileage , performance, comfort, safety etc. and have given their personal opinions about these cars.
As per the users experiences MG Astor is a winner for you if you are seriously looking for comfort, maintenance and features in your car. But Tata Punch is better on the grounds of mileage and safety. On the basis of performance user have rated both the cars equally.
Before making your decision you should also consider the unbiased and thorough analysis of these cars on every aspect by our auto experts who have summarised the analysis in pros, cons and final conclusion..
| Ratings Factor | Astor | Punch |
|---|---|---|
| Mileage | 3.2 | 3.5 |
| Performance | 3.9 | 3.9 |
| Comfort | 4.5 | 4.4 |
| Maintenance | 3.9 | 3.7 |
| Safety | 4.4 | 4.7 |
| Features | 4.5 | 4.3 |
Do you own a Car or a Bike?
- Interact with community
- Become a Top Contributor
Add Car
Add Bike
Videos of MG Motor Astor and Tata Punch
-
Top 5 Concept Cars From Auto Expos | What happened to them? | Zig Fast Forward 6 Jan, 2023 3113 views
-
Tata 2023 Auto Expo Lineup | Almost 50 Cars At The Expo?! 8 Jan, 2023 3258 views
-
Honda Elevate vs Creta, Seltos, Grand Vitara, Taigun/Kushaq & Astor | The Compact SUV Deep Dive 30 Aug, 2023 10294 views
-
MG Astor Review: Should the Hyundai Creta be worried? 30 Sep, 2021 26809 views
-
MG Astor First Impressions | It’s A Real Threat, Here’s Why 19 Sep, 2021 29886 views
-
MG Astor 2021 | What You Need To Know | Beyond The AI Bot! 15 Sep, 2021 11044 views
-
MG ZS Petrol First Look Review | Auto Expo 2020 5 Feb, 2020 13670 views
-
Tata Punch vs Citroën C3| Mini SUVs Tested! | Handling, Ride & Performance Comparison | ZigWheels.com 27 Dec, 2022 13514 views
-
Tata’s Punch: Here to knock out hatchbacks? 9 Oct, 2021 31763 views
MG Astor Comparison with Similar Cars
-
MGAstorRs. 9.99 LakhvsAstor vs Urban Cruiser Hyryder
ToyotaUrban Cruiser HyryderRs. 11.14 Lakh
Tata Punch Comparison with Similar Cars
Latest News on MG Motor Astor and Tata Punch
-
MG Hector Gets A Cool Looking Snowstorm Edition At Rs 21.53 Lakh25 Sep, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels -
All About The Tata Punch Camo Edition Explained In 10 Real-life Images18 Oct, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
-
New MG Astor (ZS Hybrid) Revealed In The UK, Could Be Launched As A Facelift For Existing Car In India29 Aug, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
-
2024 Nissan Magnite Facelift Vs Tata Punch: Specifications Compared10 Oct, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
-
MG Launches New Range Of Accessories For Comet, Hector, Astor, ZS EV And Gloster7 Jun, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
-
Tata Punch Camo Edition Is Back! Priced From Rs 8.45 Lakh4 Oct, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
-
MG Astor 100 Year Limited Edition: Check It Out In 10 Images21 May, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
-
Updated Tata Punch Introduced With New Variants And Features, Sunroof Now More Accessible!17 Sep, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
-
2024 MG Astor Becomes The Most Affordable Compact SUV In India At Rs 9.98 Lakh12 Jan, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
-
Maruti Suzuki Swift CNG Vs Tata Punch CNG: Which Eco-friendly Vehicle Should You Pick?13 Sep, 2024 | By Team ZigWheels
Recently Asked User Questions
Q. Which car is best between Punch and Exter?
- Punch build quality is good
- Both cars are good in their own forte. Tata Punch is good for city commutes but out on the highway, it lacks outright power which stops it from being versatile. Other than that it is hard to flaw this impressive car. It is spacious and comfortable, it is pretty well loaded and thanks to the option packs, even the lower variants can be customized to your requirements. On the other hand, the Exter knows its audience well and that makes the job easier for us. It gets a lot of things right, like the cabin experience, space, practicality, comfort, ease of drive, and boot space. And the features list is so good that it will be very hard to beat it in under Rs 10 lakh. The Hyundai Exter’s suspension balance is a sensible one. Given that it is going to spend most of its kilometres in the city, the suspension is set up on the softer side. We drove the Exter over bumpy roads, off the road and on the broken roads – and we can say that the suspension is very balanced. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test ride before making the final decision. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealership details.
Q. Which is a better car, Tata Punch or Tata Tigor?
- Both cars are good in their own forte. Tata Punch is good for city commutes but out on the highway, it lacks outright power which stops it from being versatile. Other than that it is hard to flaw this impressive car. It is spacious and comfortable, it is pretty well loaded and thanks to the option packs, even the lower variants can be customized to your requirements. On the other hand, If you are looking for a compact sedan with a brilliant safety package, impressive design, and a decent list of features, then you may opt for the Tata Tigor. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive before making the final decision. Follow the link and select your desired city for details.
Q. Which is better Tata Punch or Tata Nexon?
- Both cars are good in their own forte. The Nexon might feel a little rough around the edges if it's polished and the latest tech you're after. On the other hand, Tata Punch is good for city commutes but out on the highway, it lacks outright power which stops it from being versatile. Other than that it is hard to flaw this impressive car. It is spacious and comfortable, it is pretty well loaded and thanks to the option packs, even the lower variants can be customized to your requirements. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive before making the final decision. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealershipdetails.
MG Motor Astor Vs Tata Punch FAQs
Which car is best between MG Motor Astor vs Tata Punch?
As per the users experiences MG Astor is a winner for you if you are seriously looking for comfort, maintenance and features in your car. But Tata Punch is better on the grounds of mileage and safety. On the basis of performance user have rated both the cars equally.
Which car is cheaper MG Motor Astor vs Tata Punch?
The Tata Punch is cheaper than MG Astor by Rs. 8.19 Lakh.
Which car has better mileage MG Motor Astor vs Tata Punch?
The Tata Punch delivers better mileage 18.8 Kmpl.
Which car offers better performance MG Motor Astor vs Tata Punch?
For the Savvy Pro Sangria Turbo AT version, 1349 cc Petrol engine of Astor produces 138.08bhp@5600rpm of power and 220Nm@3600rpm of torque. Whereas for the Creative Plus S Camo AMT version, 1199 cc Petrol engine of Punch produces 87bhp@6000rpm of power and 115Nm@3150-3350rpm of torqueAs per the users experiences in terms of performance both are same.
Images of Tata Punch and MG Astor
Which one do you like more?
Astor
Punch
×