×

MG Astor vs Tata Punch

MG Astor Price starts at Rs. 9.78 Lakh which is Rs. 4.29 Lakh costlier than base model of Tata Punch priced at Rs. 5.49 Lakh. The claimed mileage . In technical specifications, MG Astor (Top Model) is powered by 1498 cc engine , while Tata Punch (Top Model) is powered by 1199 cc engine. 50% users have chosen Tata Punch over MG Motor Astor in a survey being conducted on zigwheels.com.

MG Astor vs Tata Punch Comparison

Key Highlights Astor Punch KWID
Ex-Showroom Price Rs. 17.38 Lakh Rs. 9.09 Lakh Rs. 4.58 Lakh
Fuel Type Petrol Petrol Petrol
Engine Displacement 1349 cc 1199 cc 999 cc
Power 138.08bhp@5600rpm 84.48bhp@6000rpm 67bhp@5500rpm
Mileage ... 18.82 Kmpl 21.74 Kmpl
Read More

MG Astor vs Tata Punch Summary

Basic Info Astor Savvy Turbo ATPunch Creative AMTKWID 1.0 RXL
Brand MG Motor Tata Renault
Ex-Showroom Price Rs. 17.38 Lakh View On Road Price Rs. 9.09 Lakh View On Road Price Rs. 4.58 Lakh View On Road Price
Rating
4.3
(11 Ratings)
4.4
(60 Ratings)
3.8
(827 Ratings)
Engine Displacement 1349 cc 1199 cc 999 cc
Body Type SUVAll SUV Cars SUVAll SUV Cars HatchbackAll Hatchback Cars
Fuel Type Petrol Petrol Petrol
Max Power 138.08bhp@5600rpm 84.48bhp@6000rpm 67bhp@5500rpm
No Of Cylinders 4 3 3
Transmission Automatic Automatic Manual
Gear Box 6 Speed 5 Speed 5 Speed
Drive Type ... FWD FWD
Colors
Astor Colors
Punch Colors
KWID Colors
Mileage (ARAI) ... 18.82 Kmpl 21.74 Kmpl
Tyre Size 215/55 R17 195/60 R16 165/70 R14
Boot Space ... 366 Liters 279 Liters
Steering Mounted Audio Control Yes Yes No
Cruise Control Yes Yes No
Airbags Driver, Passenger and Side Front Driver and Passenger Driver
Insurance Rs. 75,565 Astor Insurance Rs. 38,443 Punch Insurance Rs. 26,925 KWID Insurance

Engine Type
220TURBO
1.2 Revotron Petrol
Petrol Engine
Engine Displacement
1349 cc
1199 cc
999 cc
Fuel Type
Petrol
Petrol
Petrol
Max Power
138.08bhp@5600rpm
84.48bhp@6000rpm
67bhp@5500rpm
Max Torque
220nm@3600rpm
113nm@3300rpm+/-100 rpm
91nm@4250rpm
Emission Norm Compliance
BS VI
BS VI
BS VI
No Of Cylinders
4
3
3
Transmission
Automatic
Automatic
Manual
Gear Box
6 Speed
5 Speed
5 Speed
Valves Per Cylinder
4
4
4
Drive Type
...
FWD
FWD
Valve Configuration
...
...
DOHC
Paddle Shift
...
...
Fuel Supply System
...
...
MPFi
Turbo Charger
...

Braking (100-0 kmph)
...
47.19 Meters
...
Braking (80-0 kmph)
...
30.32 Meters
...
Mileage (ARAI)
...
18.82 Kmpl
21.74 Kmpl
0-100 kmph
...
...
16 Sec

Suspension Front
MacPherson Strut
Independent, Lower Wishbone, McPherson Strut with Coil Spring
MacPherson strut with lower transverse link
Suspension Rear
Torsion Beam
Rear Semi Independent Twist Beam with Coil Spring and Shock Absorber
Twist beam suspension with coil spring
Brakes Front
Disc
Disc
Disc
Brakes Rear
Disc
Drum
Drum
Steering Type
Electronic
Power
Electric
Minimum Turning Radius
...
...
4.9 metres
Tyre Size
215/55 R17
195/60 R16
165/70 R14
Wheel Size
...
...
14
Alloy Wheel Size
R17
R16
...
Tyre Type
Tubeless,Radial
Tubeless,Radial
Tubeless,Radial

Dual Tone Dashboard
Ventilated Seats
...
...
Additional Interior Features
Interior Theme - Tuxedo Black(Optional), Perforated Leather Seat Upholstery with Stitching Detail, Brit Dynamic Emblem on Dashboard, Full Digital Cluster with 17.78 cm Embedded LCD Screen, LED Interior Map Lamp, Premium Leather# Layering on Dashboard, Door Trim, Door Armrest and Centre Console with Stitching Details, Premium Soft Touch Dashboard, Satin Chrome Highlights to Door Handles, Air Vents and Steering Wheel
Rear Flat Floor,7" TFT Instrument Cluster
White stitched metal grey fabric upholstery,Stylised gear knob,Gear knob bellow,Black centre fascia,Front seats: Outer valence cover - small,LED Digital instrument cluster,On-board trip computer
Fabric Upholstery
Leather Seats
Rear Seat Headrest
Seating Capacity
5
5
5
Doors
5
5
5
Boot Space
...
366 Liters
279 Liters
Fuel Capacity
45 Liters
37 Liters
28 Liters

Alloy Wheels
Lighting
LED Headlights,DRL's (Day Time Running Lights),LED Tail lamps,Cornering Fog lights
DRL's (Day Time Running Lights),Projector Headlights,LED Tail lamps
DRL's (Day Time Running Lights),LED Tail lamps
Trunk Opener
...
...
Lever
Additional Exterior Features
Full LED Hawkeye Headlamps with Black Highlights, Bold Celestial Grille, Outside Door Handle with Chrome Highlights, Rear Bumper with Chrome Accentuated Dual Exhaust Design, Satin Silver Finish Roof Rails, Front & Rear Bumper Skid Plate - Glossy Black Finish, Door Garnish - Glossy Black Finish, Red Brake Callipers - Front & Rear, R17 Turbine Inspired Machined Alloys, Sporty Black ORVM, Wheel & Side Cladding-Black, High-Gloss Finish Fog Light Surround
R16 Diamond Cut Alloys,Body Coloured ORVM, ODH, Door,Wheel Arch & Sill Cladding,Puddle Lamps
New stylish graphite grille,Body coloured bumpers,SUV-styled Headlamps,Silver streak LED DRL,Tail lamps with LED light guides,Wheel arch cladding,Side indicator on wheel arch cladding,Integrated roof spoiler,Tinted glazing,Black hub cap,Full Wheel Cover - Sparkling silver,Stylised graphic
Outside Rear View Mirror
Turn indicators on ORVM
Xenon Headlights
...
...
Trunk Light
...
Rear Spoiler
Antenna
Roof Rails
Length*Width*Height
4323*1809*1650 mm^3
3827*1742*1615 mm^3
3731*1579*1474 mm^3
Wheelbase
2585 mm
2445 mm
2422 mm
Ground Clearance (Unladen)
...
187 mm
184 mm

In Car Entertainment (Audio)
...
...
Single DIN Stereo with Radio AM/FM,MP3
Connectivity
Android Auto,Apple CarPlay
Android Auto,Apple CarPlay
...
Addtional Comfort Features
Rear Seat Middle Headrest, Leather# Driver Armrest With Storage, Driver and Co-Driver Vanity Mirror, Remote AC On/Off & Temperature Setting, Rear Parcel Shelf, PM 2.5 Filter, Electronic Power Steering with Mode Adjust (Normal, Urban, Dynamic), Seat Back Pockets, Dual Horn, All Doors Maps Pocket & Bottle Holders
Central Remote Locking With Flip Key,90-Degree Door Opening
Pollen filter,HVAC control function - 3 speed & 3 position,Driver & Co Driver Sunvisor,12V power socket - Front,Cabin light with theatre dimming,Rear seats: foldable backrest
USB Charger
Front & Rear
Front
Not Available
Central Control Armrest
With Storage
...
Not Available
Tailgate Ajar
...
...
Gear Shift Indicator
...
...
Rear Curtain
...
...
Not Available
Luggage Hook and Net
...
...
Battery Saver
...
...
Lane Change Indicator
...
Additional Entertainment Features
i-SMART : Connected Car Features, Personal AI Assistant Head Turner : Smart Movement in Direction of Voice, Ask Anything : Uses Wikipedia Content, Local and Global News : Powered by Bing News, Interactive Emojis Including Greetings and Festival Wishes Jokes, 35+ Hinglish Voice Commands, Enhanced Chit Chat Interaction, Voice Commands Support to Control Skyroof, AC, Music, Navigation, FM, Calling & More, Digital Key with Bluetooth Technology, Discover and Book Parking Slots : Powered by MapMyIndia and Park+, Inbuilt Jio Saavn App with Premium Account for Music and Podcasts, In Car Remote Control via i-Smart App for Music and AC Controls, Live Location Sharing with friends and Family, Shortpedia News App with English and Hindi Voice Readout Support, Remote Door Lock/Unlock, I Smart App for Apple & Android Watches, Online Navigation with Live Traffic - Powered by MapMyIndia Maps, Multi Langu
Floating 7" Touchscreen Infotainment By HarmanTM,2 Tweeters
Single DIN Stereo with Radio & MP3, Bluetooth Audio Streaming & Handsfree Telephony
Smart Entry
Massage Seats
...
...
Not Available
Memory Functions For Seat
...
...
Not Available
One Touch Operating Power Windows
Driver's Window
Driver's Window
Not Available
Autonomous Parking
...
...
Not Available
Drive Modes
...
2
Internal Storage
...
...
No of Speakers
6
4
2
Rear Entertainment System
...
...
AC
Rear AC Ducts
...
Heater
Power Steering
Steering Column
Tilt & Collapsible
Tilt
...
Steering Mounted Audio Control
Cruise Control
Power Windows ( Front / Rear )
Front and Rear
Front and Rear
Front
Adjustable Driver Seat
...
Heated Seat Front
Heated Seats Rear
Adjustable Front Passenger Seat
Lumbar Support
Folding Rear Seat
60:40 Split
Bench Folding
Bench Folding
Rear Seat Center Armrest
Tachometer
Dual Trip Meter
Low Fuel Warning Lamp
Clock
...
Seat Belt Warning
...
Push Ignition
AM/FM Radio
USB Auxiliary Input
...
DVD Playback
...
...
Touch-screen Display
GPS Navigation System
...
...
Speakers Front
Speakers Rear
Automatic Head Lamps
Auto Rain Sensing Wipers
Follow me home headlamps
Adjustable Head Lights
Parking Sensors
Rear
Rear
Rear
Remote Operated Fuel Tank Lid
...
...
Front Cupholders
...
Door Pockets
Front & Rear Door
...
Front Door
12V Power Outlets
Cigarette Lighter
...
...
Bottle Holder
Front & Rear Door
...
Front Door
Sun Roof
...
Moon Roof
...

Anti-Pinch Power Windows
...
...
Speed Sensing Auto Door Lock
...
Knee Airbags
...
...
ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts
Head-Up Display
...
...
Day/Night Rearview Mirror
...
Blind Spot Monitor
...
Hill Descent Control
...
Hill Assist
...
Impact Sensing Auto Door Unlock
...
360 View Camera
...
Airbags
Driver, Passenger and Side Front
Driver and Passenger
Driver
Seat Belts
Anti-lock Braking System (ABS)
Electronic Brakeforce Distribution (EBD)
Brake Assist (BA)
...
Electronic Stability Program (ESP)
...
...
Traction Control System (TCS)
Engine Immobilizer
...
Central Locking
Child Safety Lock
Fog Lamps (Front / Rear )
Both
...
Rear Wash Wiper
Rear Defogger

Pros and Cons

  • Pros
  • Cons

MG Astor

  • Simple yet attractive design
  • comfortable seating for four
  • sets a new benchmark in terms of cabin quality
  • punchy turbo petrol engine
  • ADAS adds a layer of safety and convenience.

Tata Punch

  • The Punch pulls off muscular SUV-like looks
  • high ground clearance along with an easy to drive hatchback -like experience. Impressive cabin quality
  • clever customization options make it even more appealing. It is a sensible package that focuses on useful equipment like auto headlamps and wipers
  • electric folding wing mirrors
  • cruise control and connected car tech highlight a sensible features list. 5-star Global NCAP safety rating.

MG Astor

  • Narrow cabin makes it strictly a four-seater
  • boot space seems lesser than the competition
  • some feel-good features like ventilated seats are missing.

Tata Punch

  • No diesel engine option. The 1.2L engine
  • although good for commuting
  • lacks the power for ease of use on highway or when fully loaded. 16.5 seconds for 0-100kmph (claimed) isn't inspiring.
Image

Do you own a Car or a
Bike?

  • Interact with community
  • Become a Top Contributor

Astor and Punch Competitors

Recently Asked User Questions

Q. Punch or Wagon R, which car should I go for?
  • Both Maruti Wagon R and Tata Punch are good cars and offer a lot to their customer. Selecting one would depend on certain factors such as your budget, preference of the segment, features requirement, cabin space, safety, etc. The WagonR continues to be a sensible practical hatchback. It’s now stronger, more feature-loaded, more powerful and safer. Importantly, the prices have not gone up substantially. On the other hand, Tata Punch could be the ideal alternative for city-friendly hatchback users looking for something more rugged and versatile. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test ride for a better understanding of performance and comfort. Click on the link and select your desired city for dealership details.Read More: - 2021 Tata Punch First Drive Review: Hard Hitter! - Maruti Wagon R vs Tata Punch.
Q. Which car is more value for money, Magnite or Punch?
  • Both the cars are good in their forte. The Nissan Magnite has a lot of potential as a family car. It’s spacious, practical, well loaded and considering its aggressive pricing, will be a strong alternative to the low-mid range variants of its popular competitors. On the other hand, The Punch pulls off muscular SUV-like looks, high ground clearance along an easy to drive hatchback -like experience. Impressive cabin quality, clever customization options make it even more appealing. It is a sensible package that focuses on useful equipment like auto headlamps and wipers, electric folding wing mirrors, cruise control and connected car tech highlight a sensible features list. 5-star Global NCAP safety rating. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive before making the final decision. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealership details.Read more -Nissan Magnite: First Drive Review.-2021 Tata Punch First Drive Review: Hard Hitter!.-Tata Punch Customers Have To Wait Up To Four Months To Get Their SUV.-Tata Punch Accessory Packs And Their Prices Detailed.
Q. Which is the best car between Tata HBX and Nissan Magnite?
  • It's magnite turbo because it's got 100 ps and 160 NM torque
  • No sir Nissan has no resale valueso punch is best
  • Hbx
View All Answers
More Questions

Popular Cars Comparison

  • Trending
  • SUV
  • Hatchback
  • Sedan
  • Luxury
Compare Cars