Indiatimes  |  
    ZigWheels
 
Home Buy & Sell News & Features Gallery Special Coverage Interact
Reviews

<< previous   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9    next >>   
Untitled Document
Tata Manza Special Coverage
 
Road Test: Tata Indica Vista 1.3 Quadrajet

29 Aug 2008

The second generation Indica is outstanding for its segment, punches way above it and is brilliantly positioned to grab sales from almost all sections of the B-segment spectrum. And beyond! says Adil Jal Darukhanawala and the Zigwheels team after the first ever road test of this segment buster.





Ford Endeavour
The new Indica Vista is a conundrum as much as it is a brilliant new B-segment contendor. Contrast it with its original from a decade ago and you would have got a gawky upright car trying to blend in with the scenery - read that as Marutis - but not succeeding. This inability to blend in was also the reason for its commercial success, to the tune of almost 900,000 units produced and sold to date (with another 200,000 units plus for the saloon and estate versions on the same platform).

More in this Review :
 Slideshow : Indica Vista
 
 Indica Vista Vs.Competition
 See Variant & price
 Get on road price

Related Reviews :
 Swift Diesel
 Diesel Comparo

To date every car maker has marvelled at the Indica package but stayed in the comfort zone given that it catered to a hardy robust type of customer. Well gentlemen, that image is going to change: the hardy robust appeal will remain but this now comes clothed in a smartly cut set of clothes adorning a finely toned body with athleticism and stamina to match. Throw in performance, fuel efficiency, great road manners and presence plus genuinely strong build quality and suddenly you are looking not at catching the others but towering over them!

Yes this may indeed be a bolt from the blue but take it from us this is deserved appreciation. Especially for an all new, from-the-ground-up automobile with the Tata logo placed firmly on the smily face of India's first indigenously developed automobile. Of course in its second avatar the Indica breaks another tenet from the original - it has tried not to reinvent the wheel but take the alliance route for critical aggregates. It is fitting that Tata Motors' powertrain deal with Fiat will manifest itself first in the Indica Vista - ironic in that the original Indica effectively saw off Fiat's very own Palio creation so very effortlessly some years ago.

However as many say an engine alone doesn't make a car or as Jagdish Khattar, former head honcho of Maruti Suzuki said: "People buy cars, not engines," and perhaps he was hinting, tongue-very-much-in-cheek at what was in the realm of possibility for Tata Motors. In fact as the Indica Vista has proved in the course of this first ever road test in the country, the designers and engineers at Tata Motors actually heard him and delivered a product which is outstanding for its segment, punches way above it and is brilliantly positioned to grab sales from almost all sections of the B-segment spectrum. And beyond!

It might seem unthinkable but the finished product rolling out of Tata Motors' modern facility in Pune is proof that Indian enterprise can hack it big time. That the Indica Vista comes when its maker has been dragged into the politically loaded Singur impasse (not of its making), is also ample proof of how much Tata Motors has progressed in the car business since December 1998. Maturity comes in many forms but Tata Motors has displayed this by getting the large hatchback Vista spot on. Our detailed road test says it all.

 
 

<< previous   1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9    next >>   

Launches of 2010


User's Comments
  • Ashu (14 May 2010 15:46)
    i bought Indica vista quadrajet (Aqua) on Dec 25 2009 ... my daily drive is around 130 Km ....and till now i have covered 14575 Km .....According to me...its the best car in this price (4.58 lakhs on road) till now i have not faced any problem........and i have checked its FE many times it comes around 18KM/Ltr full AC and 21 KM without AC...great suspension, good pickup.....TATA ROCKS..... | Reply
  • Iyappan (01 May 2010 10:54)
    null | Reply
  • Iyappan (01 May 2010 10:54)
    null | Reply
  • IRFAN (23 April 2010 15:42)
    please suggest me indicaDLS, or vista TDI | Reply
  • Senthil (15 February 2010 23:57)
    Today I tested Indica vista quadrajet aura in heavy Bangalore traffic. After all I didnt realise that i was driving it in 3rd gear for a long time. It gave a nice puch in the heavy traffic. Pricing is simply superb... no one can beat Tata... The space is amazing and as the other reviewers say about its fuel efficiency.. I'm booking Quadrajet Aura tomorrow. | Reply
 iyappan (01 May 2010 10:58) Reply to Senthil
null | Reply
 Iyappan (01 May 2010 10:57) Reply to Senthil
null | Reply
  • Gaurav (21 December 2009 20:30)
    can someone tell me which one is better quadrajet or safire. I won't drive much. | Reply
 Chicken Vindaloo (08 March 2010 17:52) Reply to Gaurav
If U not going to drive much, then what do U want the car for? | Reply
 a g  (14 May 2010 17:37) Reply to Chicken Vindaloo
Saffire is the 1200cc 65 bhp engine developed from Fiat. Quadrajet is the 1300 cc 75 bhp engine developed in collaboration with fiat, Marti, and a few others. On road Quadrajet behaves better than any other petrol engine in its class. so choice is yours. If you don't drive much why don't you go for Swift/ritz petrol. Both are in the same price range. If you are a diehard Tata Fan like me go for a quadrajet engine. | Reply
  • Balu Nagaraj (08 November 2009 19:02)
    I bought a vista aura quadrajet in july 2009 and have covered about 5000 kms since. The interior space, engine power and fuel efficiency is good at 19-20 kmph on highways. Interior plastic quality has to be improved and also the power window switches, interior door handles need improvement. Service of the dealer at secunderabad, Autofin motors has been good. | Reply
  • Arun Kumar (29 October 2009 12:57)
    Have been driving Indica Vista Aura for last one year, I was very terrified with the experience of the old indica, but I decidedto buy vista on the basis that the engine and gear box was from Fiat, which has proven itself in Suzuki Swift, I have had no problems till date and is giving me a decent milage of 18 in crowded city conditions, the interiors are much much better in quality, better insulation from vibration and sound of the engine, I am glad that I bought this car which is really value for money, very spacious car with lot of goodies put makes a very good driving experience. It certianly lacks with the absence of ABS, Climate control, Airbags, motorised side mirror operations.... | Reply
 Mehul Shah (27 January 2010 10:16) Reply to Arun Kumar
RE: VISTA SAFIRE (AURA)Could you please tell me what average do yo get i.e. fuel economy. Is it underpowered as others claim? Is it wise to go for Diesel If you drive less than 10k per year?1. I need spacious car. 2. fuel economy 3. speed | Reply
 Arun Kumar (04 February 2010 14:49) Reply to Mehul Shah
It seems that the petrol version (safire) is underpowered and low on fuel on economy. It would not be wise to buy a diesel car if you dive is limited to just 10k kms, since at the same price you could buy much better petrol car with low running cost | Reply
  • krishna (23 October 2009 10:21)
    Iam using indica vista for the past 6 months and its performance is good. | Reply
  • Rakesh (22 October 2009 21:02)
    My experience with 04 model Indica Petrol has been excellent. It has logged 90K, no clutch work, no suspension work.....in fact nothing major.In my recent trip to Delhi - Chandigarh - Del;hi it returned FE of 15 , AC on all the time. I see a lot of _ve coments for Indica, My experience is different. I think 2nd Gen. Indica is much better. I see one Indian brand not only improving steadily but has the guts to go global. We should not undermine this effort. | Reply
  • N R KANNAN (13 October 2009 00:54)
    Tata has to go a long way if it has to be counted in the same league as Suzuki, Hyundai and others. Pathetic right from delivery point to service. Dealer yet to refund excess amt collected. Faulty swithces yet to be replaced even after 8 weeks. These went out of order within 2 weeks of purchase. Pros : Good engine and driving comfort - so far as city driving is concerned a good vehicle. Cons : Tata Service - nightmare | Reply
 Anup (11 November 2009 12:27) Reply to N R KANNAN
PalHyundai or Suzuki stand nowhere near Tatas as they initially just copied the European or American models whereas Tatas have developed cars on there own. This requre guts. | Reply
 siva (02 March 2010 17:59) Reply to Anup
Tata has guts.Agreed. But I do not have such guts. The only atttraction in Tata cars is their attractive/ economical prices. The suspension needs a lot of improvement and the tyre wear is very fast as I could hear from many wheel balancing firms. The resale value of Tata cars are low as compared to Maruti or Hyundai. Can you show me in the Indian roads, a car of Tata's which has run for a little over a decade? Whereas you can find many of Maruti or Hyundai. That is the reliability of these cars even in Indian conditions. | Reply
 HITESH (02 August 2010 14:38) Reply to siva
buddy !!!!! we have tata sumo DL 8 CB 8229 !!! IT IS 1997 MODEL AND HAS DONE 4.5 LAC KMS !!!! IT STILL TOUCHES 100 KM/ HR!!! now wat do u say
  • Mishra (10 October 2009 14:40)
    A nice review. Please advise which car should I buy between the latest zen estilo and indica vista quadrajet. I do not need much space and would be comfortable with the estilo even. But total cost of running the vehicle is a deciding factor. Please advise. Mishra. | Reply
  • Umesh (09 October 2009 15:23)
    @ManishYou are comparing apples and oranges. A petrol car that weighs 300 Kg less will give better straight line drag results.~Umesh() | Reply
  • Petrol Head (29 September 2009 15:03)
    I own a VISTA Quadrajet as well as a SWIFT. Both vehicles are used on a daily basis. My observations are:VISTAPro's:Space, Rear Seat Comfort, Mid-Range performance, Visibility, Supple Suspension, High speed stabilityCon's:Cabin plastic quality inconsistent, Narrow footwell, Not as "flickable" as the SWIFT, Oversized Steering wheel, Brake fade at high speedsSWIFT:Pro's:Cocky looks, Peppy acceleration, Fantastic handling around the twisties, "point - and - shoot - ability, Slick gearshift, Progressive brakesCon's:Dark | Reply
  • Manish (30 August 2009 21:31)
    0-100 in 21 sec........its not at all good,.... even a 800cc alto do it in 20 sec........this shows how underpowered this hatch is...... | Reply
 Vikram Chopra (02 November 2009 18:38) Reply to Manish
Have an Alto.... it sucks. The chassis resonance vibration has still not been attended to despite 5 regular services. Switch on the AC and I could overtake you on a bicycle. Driven the Vista Quadrajet all over the hills of Himachal, even with the AC on it has sufficient reserve power. Suggest you drive the car then pass judgement. I for one will never buy a Maruti product again. Anything but Maruti after this horrible Alto experience. | Reply
 abhi (06 November 2009 11:54) Reply to Vikram Chopra
just race it with swift a.c on uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu will defintely have a butt watch | Reply
  • Raquib (28 August 2009 09:01)
    Indica's 'indi' represents India. So is Indigo. | Reply
  • Sandip Vaidya (27 August 2009 14:18)
    indica vista is excellent in b segment.Only mistake Tata made is naming car indica again. They should go for different name | Reply
  • Cruise Cric (26 August 2009 11:04)
    I have driven Vista Saffire and Quadra, but saffire lacks the punch when you shift from one gear to next. It seems the saffire engine is underpowered for handling the weight of the car. I guess 70-75 bhp petrol could have been better. The swift Lxi petrol is better then Vista petrol. But when you are paying 4.55 lacs for Swift petrol, i think its better to pay 5 lacs for a fully loaded vista quadrajet. Atleast you will have a much better mileage and hassle free power train to harp about. | Reply
  • adi (25 August 2009 18:47)
    indica vista is the most pathetic car in india (after indica)..i'v had as many as 18 different problems in just 3 months..even worse that co. says 6 of them cant b resurrected..marutis | Reply
  • Uday (21 August 2009 18:11)
    I have had lot of test drives on Indica Vista, the power and feel of driving is just amazing. Comfort cant be matched to any of the other cars of the same segment. The best part I felt is, with the same engine and comfort level the price is cheaper than Marutis and Hyundai's. Lovely | Reply
  • Satish (17 August 2009 13:50)
    Hi,Im planning to book Indiaca Vista Aura Safire (red colour) next Sunday. I have opted for “Prerana Motors” in Sarjapur Road. I have few questions on the same1. Do u have any idea of the dealer I selected? are they good?2.What all accessories should I buy for this version?3.What all accessories should I ask the dealer free of cost?4. What colour seat cover shoudl I go for considering red colout of the car?Cheers,Satish | Reply
 Kishore (27 October 2009 17:47) Reply to Satish
Hi Satish,dont go for prerana. i had very bad experience with them. in single statement i can say they took 4 days to deliver my vehicle | Reply
  • BHUPESH SINGH (13 August 2009 13:29)
    NEVER BUY VISTA OR INDICA IN LIFE OR YOU WILL SUFFER LIKE ME IN TERMS OF POOR QUALITY PARTS AND SERVICE. | Reply
 Amit (30 October 2009 11:40) Reply to BHUPESH SINGH
Well How can u say this !!!!My dear friend just check the roads and find how many tata cars are running. If these cars have such poor quality then you wont see them on roads.... Improve ur knowledge | Reply
  • M S Sharma (12 August 2009 15:31)
    Well the TATAs have done it again | Reply
  • Aashish (12 August 2009 12:12)
    I own a Tata Indigo 2005 TDI and the reason y i will never ever go for tata cars are following.1). The stability is not up to the mark u apply brakes a bit more harder the car will skid as if u r driving on a ice.2). the refinment both in engine and interiors are not gud(i can see wires from the drivers position when i bought indigo come on this is not acceptable).3). the shock absorbers are not gud, u wud have to get them changed after almost every 50000 kms.4). the clutch needs to be changed after every 40000 kms. | Reply
  • SAM (12 August 2009 00:58)
    Reasons why I will not go for Vista are 1. Flimsy interior. 2. Absence of ABS/EBD and Airbags as an option. 3. Indica like rear tail lights. 4. The word "Indica" in the name. 5. Low quality front bumper. 6. Tyres. 7. Looks dated after a while on road. I would rather go for Fiat Punto. Other then all these points Vista is a good car. | Reply
  • Amol (11 August 2009 18:17)
    I wish Tata has fitted it with ABS and Airbags. Even Maruti's A star is fitted with these safety devices. | Reply
  • Sabyasachi Sinha (07 August 2009 10:26)
    Go for Vista:-1. Roomy - everybody who sits in my car even swift owners they say has got lot of space.2. approx 40k cheaper think wht u can do with it- alloy wheels, zaazzy interior refitment, very good sound sytem with video option still left some money, alas can't do in swift cough extra money 30k more to have these.3. same engine better drive in city.4. Swift has one better thing finishing of interior i.e. it takes margin by half point(got finishing but black interior vs little bit naggy finishing but two tone interior it's bit refreshing....Hope u decide...choice is urs moneys is urs....as both cars are good....having some advantages | Reply
  • Pradip (17 July 2009 21:46)
    I been driving Quadrajet for quite a few months.Miraculous engine. No vibration, no sound.And pick up is superb.My be that is similar to Swift DDIS but one front where Vista bests in its class for the space and pricing.I am steadily an average of 20.5 on highways and partly on city.One can go blindly for it. This gives you much more than you pay. | Reply
  • ravee (15 July 2009 16:59)
    for daily running of 50km, which will better among indica vista, indigo, M,disre | Reply
  • Giridhar (12 July 2009 11:23)
    HELP!! i am really really confused.. have to decide between swift , indica vista , getz all diesel versions, my main criteria is space and drivability is bangalore city traffic.. | Reply
  • Abhijit (18 June 2009 10:58)
    My experience is contrary to the description in the road test. Rear seat ride comfort is very poor. | Reply
  • Anonymous (18 June 2009 04:23)
    I completely agree with below review by Akhtar.Akhtar (30 April 2009 23:54:02) I have been driving Indica Vista "aura" since six months now. Excellent car, very good value for money. The cabin is roomy and airy , very good all round vision.I only wish I could have wider and bigger tyres fitted. Would make the car look GREAT. Hats off to TATA MOTORS. They do make us INDIANS feel good. | Reply
  • Krishan (17 June 2009 19:34)
    Lot of improvements from the older Indica version. Spacious than any other car in its category. Still, the Cab look disappoints. Music system can be improved (better than other diesel models that don't offer one). Still an Indica is an Indica, even TATA offers it for free. . | Reply
  • Maappu (17 June 2009 12:28)
    I've had mixed reviews about the Vista from another review site. Many have complained about the underpowered AC and the lack of zip in the throttle when compared to other cars the category. Though I'm favoring the buy the i20 the cost of the Vista makes it attractive. | Reply
  • nilesh (15 June 2009 14:30)
    I will lay my hands on a Vista Quadra Aura tomorrow. I totally agree that the Vista Quadra is phenomenal improvement, Much better VFM than swift considering it can seat 5 adults ia a comforth that swift cannot even dream off! not to mention the sturdy body, split seats, lumbar support, 2 din, etc etc...numerous goodies which a swift vdi does not offer!! Cheers to Ratan Tata for bringing out such a fabulous car! | Reply
  • Daddy Cool (11 June 2009 18:17)
    Vikram, which car do you owe bro? Let me guess - A rattling Maruti.Have you even sat in the Vista, let alone drive one? If so then what was the fault found by you? Just because some 1 told you that the Swift is better, dont just shake your head in agreement to it like a monkey. | Reply
  • Bhagwan Man (11 June 2009 18:11)
    Sumit - Tata's have improved their service considerably. I have had my fair share of problems initially with the car, but the workshop guys were not only quick in discovering the problem, but also rectifying the same at the earliest.Swift is a fantastic car for people who are single | Reply
  • Sumit Maitra (19 May 2009 02:03)
    @VikramSwift is a good looking car with lots of frills and fancies. I wanted to own one myself, but I have an India Petrol. The Vista is a much bigger car than the swift, it's going to be more comfortable and as the reviewer said the FE comparisons are skewed because they used a different (more stringent approach) for the Vista.My only concern is the after sales service which sucks for TATA. Though they are trying very hard. | Reply
  • Akhtar (30 April 2009 23:54)
    I have been driving Indica Vista "aura" since six months now. Excellent car, very good value for money. The cabin is roomy and airy , very good all round vision.I only wish I could have wider and bigger tyres fitted. Would make the car look GREAT. Hats off to TATA MOTORS. They do make us INDIANS feel good. | Reply
  • Vikram (30 April 2009 17:56)
    I dont understand the verdict. For some 30k more you get the same engine which has been tuned for better efficiency and better performance in Swift and not to mention the name of Maruti. What makes Vista the winner then ??? | Reply
  • Glenn Duarte (21 April 2009 06:37)
    Having owned and driven the older version of Indica DLs for 7 years, i have now moved to the quadrajet.A real pleasure to drive and your review is so precise to a point. Wider tyres are now fitted by Tatas. What is the widest size that can be used ? ; without effecting the performance of the vehicle. | Reply
  • dandrick (08 March 2009 22:50)
    Hello. And Bye. | Reply
  • Alex Mathew (01 March 2009 00:15)
    I have just booked and Indica Vista Qjet, this article explains all the positives and negatives of the Car. Simply SUPERB!! | Reply
  • dk verma (09 January 2009 09:32)
    Very useful article. I'm a big fan of Ratan Tata for his sterling business operations. I intend to include Vista in my current fleet that already contains an Indica DLG. Long live Ratan Tata. | Reply
Comment on this article
*Mandatory
*Your Comment :
*Your Name :
*Your E-mail :
*Word Verification :
Letters are case-sensitive

Search Reviews
Make
Model



Two Wheelers

 
Vespa all set to come back to India
First Ride: The new Bajaj Auto Discover 150 DTSi
Royal Enfield's Tour of the Rann of Kutch - Good 'ol salt-of-the-earth adventure...
Navroze Contractor's Australia Ride
The Heritage High

Top News

 
Micra takes Nissan sales through the roof
India's Gill kings Rally Queensland
Ford to export Figo to 50 new markets
Hyundai Santa Fe to be launched in October
Nissan to take booking of Leaf
  Archives>>  

All entries are compulsory
Your Question
Your Name
Your E-mail


Zig Poll
Shop @ Zigwheels.com
Car Audio Mobile Accessories Other Accessories Car Perfumes Car video Accessories Toy Cars Cleaning products
Hot on Zigwheels
Tips for safe driving
Tips for safe driving and more...
Safety is one of the most essential factors...
 Tackling the Monsoon
 Tips for Long drive
 Child Attention!
 Winter Driving tips
More...
ENVIROMENTAL CORNER
ENVIROMENTAL CORNER
The world is facing a severe fuel crisis...
 Ways to save fuel
 Why buy Hybrids car
 Ways to Drive Green
More...
 
 
MAINTENANCE CORNER
MAINTENANCE CORNER SPECIAL PACKAGE
A vehicle that is maintained well will...
 Tips to run your car
 Engine Care Tips
 Tips for the Service Center
 Interior Detailing
More...
GADGETS CORNER
GADGETS CORNER
From gizmos to apparel with an automotive...
 Apparel
 Accessories
 Other Stuff
More...
 
 
Join Our Zigwheels Community on: orkut facebook
August 2010 Calendars
Land Rovers Kawasaki ZX-10R
Land Rovers
Kawasaki ZX-10R
  Wallpaper   Wallpaper
  Printable   Printable
Most Viewed new cars on Zigwheels
New Car
More: Delhi | Mumbai | Bangalore
Subscribe:  Rss Feed
Most Viewed used cars on Zigwheels
Used Car
More: Delhi | Mumbai | Bangalore
Copyright ©2010 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved. Advertise with us  |  Careers @ TIL |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy  |  Sitemap  |  Contact us