Indiatimes  |  
    ZigWheels
 
Home Buy & Sell Reviews Gallery Special Coverage Interact
News Stories
   Print Print |
Untitled Document
 
 

Tata Nano is a tough cookie!


By: Adil Jal Darukhanawala, Editor-in-chief, ZigWheels.com   29 July 2009

Tata Nano is a tough cookie!

The world's cheapest car, the Tata Nano, has proved itself to be as innovative as its makers intended it to be. One more milestone in the Nano's brief but eventful journey so far has confirmed that this no frills, small car paradigm-shifter is not just the cleanest automobile in the country from a tail-pipe emissions perspective but it has also been proven that low cost doesn't come at the cost of in-built safety.

 Related Link
 Tata Nano Special Coverage

Proof of this came in the course of a crash test conducted, not at the firm's renowned Engineering Research Centre (ERC) in Pune (which has the country's first and probably the best crash test facility), but the crash certification facilities at the Motor Industry Research Association (MIRA) in the UK. Tata Motors in the course of its extensive development programme in India had already subjected the Nano's structure to both computer analysis and crash simulations along with actual crash testing of various prototypes before signing off the car for final production. The Nano already confirms to Indian crash worthiness regulations having been subjected to the 48km/h full frontal impact test, the static door crush test and also the roof crush test.

New Chevrolet Aveo

The test at the MIRA was done to validate Tata Motors' efforts to be in line with current European legislation what with the firm's avowed intent to market the Nano Europa on the continent within the next two to three years. The crash test results for the Nano proved that it has met the current European 56km/h full frontal and side-impact crash tests including an offset-collision test, norms which would also be applicable in India by 2012. What is impressive nonetheless is that the basis of the structure being safe and sound has been validated in an emphatic manner and as we have come to understand most of the additional modifications done to the BIW (body-in-white) for this test would also manifest themselves on the production Nanos rolling out both from Pantnagar now and shortly from Sanand.

Tata Nano is a tough cookie!

ZigWheels has learnt that for the test at the MIRA, the Nano had a few critical modifications made specifically to meet the Euro test norms. The front longitudinal structure was reinforced with added support both behind the bumper and also at the firewall. Additional strengthening was incorporated into the front doors and structural foam was added to the cant rail. The lessons learnt from these modifications and the way the Nano behaved in the course of the test should provide the firm's engineers a better understanding of what needs to be done when the Nano is put through the even more stringent Euro NCAP crash tests. For the record, Tata Motors is confident that given its computational skills and the adoption of many more safety features, the Nano Europa could be aiming at a 4-star rating which for a car of its size, cabin space and price is a pretty telling indicator of the engineering capability of the firm.

Video

TATA NANO Crash Test
 
 

User's Comments
  • Marvet (10 November 2009 13:08)
    Sorry for my previous post...no offence intended | Reply
  • Marvet (20 September 2009 22:05)
    OHHOO dear Indians, This is European version of Nano model, this is not available for Indian market. Nano for Indian market cannot meet Crash test | Reply
  • Anish Kumar Singla (18 September 2009 20:55)
    Bhai aakhirkaar Bhartiya Khoon hai isme, Fooladi jism na hoga to kya hoga.... Naam Chhote or darshan bade...... Yeh hai Nano.... | Reply
  • Ajay Karanwal (18 September 2009 15:00)
    Indeed a great car, a true value to your money. | Reply
  • Manoj (16 September 2009 09:51)
    JAI HO... Nano and Mr. Ratan Tata | Reply
  • Prasad (15 September 2009 13:13)
    I am sure TATA will do a continuous improvement on the nano to make it lot more safer. U hope they soon come up with an electric version.On the horn issue, if people practice lane discipline then the usage of horn would be minimized to a large extent. | Reply
  • Sir James (03 September 2009 18:07)
    A solar powered car is demand of the time to unspell the power of Crude and subsequently the spell of Dollar ruling over the world. Nano as a platform should eleviate with a model for middle class not by reducing the price but by alienating concepts of reducing usage of biofuel. | Reply
  • jsingh (02 September 2009 11:38)
    Do all of you who have written against the use of horn actually practice the same or is just for the sake of discussion that you write this here. I have stopped using the horn for over 12 years now. I also started using the seat belt before it became a law and mandatory. IT IS FOR INDIVIDUAL ROAD USERS TO EXERCISE CAUTION AND SELF RESTRAINT - no law can do this for us! | Reply
  • jayn (30 August 2009 16:30)
    I totally agree with gspal on the horn matter. blaring horns should be strictly dealt with and only mild horns should be allowed in all vehicles. the nano - indian version has been tested for a lower speed crash test based on th average speeds on indian roads. | Reply
  • Kevin  (30 August 2009 00:21)
    this is a grat car man its onlyy $2500lol this is great india is developing... | Reply
  • Sanjib Changkakati (29 August 2009 15:19)
    Hats off to Tata Nano.I have great admiration for Tata group and this has enhenced my belief. | Reply
  • Triveni (29 August 2009 08:35)
    That's the way to go Tata and India ! Tata should now concentrate on making the Nano, a solar charged battery powered car that is safe under Indian driving conditions. There are immense possibilities for revolutionizing the way the world travels both long and short distances with an innovative platform like the Nano. Looking at the load on Indian roads, going for bigger cars is not the right thing to do. | Reply
  • telangana  (28 August 2009 10:41)
    car should be randomly picked in india and sent to uk. tata company can make tailor made car for test. may be tata company used steel bumper etc., to pass the test. any way i will not buy this car. tata nano will become idly if it will hit bis or lorry. | Reply
  • Kalpesh Rana (27 August 2009 15:41)
    I have booked Tata nano car and will be delivered between October 2009 to December 2009.Today morning i heard from some one that this car not run that much fast than other small car like maruti and indica.Now i am confuse because my dream car will come within two months at my home and i heard negative remarks about nano car.Pl. clear my doubt. | Reply
  • vinod kumar poddar  (27 August 2009 14:37)
    your article is very informative and detailed | Reply
  • gspal (26 August 2009 12:08)
    Indian car drivers and motorcyclists keep sounding the horn consistently while driving as if they are VIPs. Most have ear deafening pressure horns. Can we not think of doing away with the horn altogether so that the driver is forced to slow down when there is something in their path. | Reply
  • Arnie (20 August 2009 20:56)
    So nano europa gets frontal airbags and reinforced structural safely..And the indian ver? Is the life of Indian drivers not worth much to the Auto companies. no bias. I am an auto enthusiast. Started drivng an ambassor and moved on to a Acuras. but it hurts guys. There no way to justify the double standards of firms when they set up shop in India | Reply
  • S Manohar (15 August 2009 09:29)
    How do they test the driver's skills in India? | Reply
  • Eric Mascarenhas (10 August 2009 12:41)
    TATA SHOULD PRODUCE A PREMIUM CAR LIKE THE HONDA ACCORD,SKODA LAURA OR TOYOTA CAMRY AND SHOULD MATCH THE QUALITY OF THESE CARS IN TERMS OF TECHNOLOGY, BUILD QUALITY AND RIDE. IT IS GOOD THAT TATA HAS NANO EUROPA FOR THE EUROPEAN MARKET, THEY SHOULD PROVIDE THE SAME FOR THE INDIAN MARKET WILL HELP THEM TO BOOST THEIR SHARE OF THE MARKET IN TERMS OF SALE AND CREATE A BIG VOLUME WITH WIDEVARIETY SEGMENTS, LIKE MARUTI HAS DONE. | Reply
  • Arun Vellappallil (06 August 2009 22:13)
    Comment of Sumon,you need to understand that india is developing economy that will byepass any country in this world ,all are concerned about safety,there r freaks all over the world,that dosent mean that indians are not safety conscious nor we dont know how to handle things. | Reply
  • Sumon Kar (04 August 2009 16:56)
    Nano Europa was always made to be better that the Nano in India. It even looks far better. Nano is a great little car but Indians are hopelessly immature to handle such a brilliant little product. The Indian version of the Nano does not need to be as safe as the European one I read somewhere? All cars should be crashed test at 50kmph as theres always that village idiot who thinks he is Michael Schumacher even in a Nano. Problem is Indians do not have a clue on how to drive or have any road etiquettes. Instead of being a a vehicle to commute in it will clog up roads stopping people from going about their daily business. Truth is not everyone should have the ability to buy a car. | Reply
  • DS (03 August 2009 21:00)
    In India no one cares about safety... they prefer style plus cost effective. Many buyers don't even know about safety norms... also majority drivers are unaware of trafic rules. Style Low Price Good Milleage = superhit in India! | Reply
  • Nitin (03 August 2009 18:44)
    Safety is the first priority. | Reply
  • pavan (01 August 2009 14:17)
    In India ..Safety is the Last Priority....most of the accidents are at high speeds not at 48kmph........ | Reply
  • Sinha (01 August 2009 10:20)
    The safety features in Nano and the success in crash test would endear the car further to the users. Great, | Reply
  • kishore (31 July 2009 19:52)
    I find very interesting that some people who are saying that if they do same test on the Indian Nano, It will fail. Guys, the standard used in India is different due to low speed of vehicles. Aprreciate the efforts. ♫ There are no prisons mightier than narrow perspectives and closed minds. And your dumbness offcource.. | Reply
  • Percy (31 July 2009 16:22)
    I think its necessary to check whether the TATA Nano which are delivering to UK is similar to wat India has. I mean structure and material used to make this car. If its correct than only we can say that its a miracle. | Reply
  • JIT MAL (31 July 2009 14:26)
    I am delighted to know that Indian companies are following stringent norms before putting the vehicle on road. | Reply
  • Prashant (31 July 2009 14:19)
    Just observe the horizontal movement of the car on impact. One may not always end up a crash in a plane area; it will tumble and cause more damage inside as well as outside if it crashes in traffic or kind of closed areas. It should not tumble or jump off the track like that if it is really safer. | Reply
  • abdul kadir (31 July 2009 10:47)
    frontal tests are fine. but the nano is a rear engined car..wot happens when the car is subject to rear crashes..the first owner of nano in mumbai has been harping on the fact that i am very tensed about ythe safet of my car if anyone crashes it from behind.. | Reply
  • Sumanth (31 July 2009 10:42)
    Its better to Stop being hypocritical and accept a great invention from TATA who have put INDIA onto the Global Automotive Map.Cheers to Tata Automotive and Mr.Ratan Tata. | Reply
  • RAVINDRA (31 July 2009 10:31)
    I am happy that TATA has tried to come out with a small car, I am sure TATA can go little further in adding high technology and achiveing high milege per litre at least up to 45 to 50 which will be a noble achivement and the world will be proud of TATA. | Reply
  • Indrajit Sao (31 July 2009 09:47)
    TATA TRUST and BRAND are now WORLD Standards too.We all should be proud of our TATA Engineers | Reply
  • Ajay Garg (31 July 2009 09:35)
    Bravado,..Mr. Tata and Mr. Ravikant...You know really well how to market your mini wonder to the world...Thanks for making India proud on global automotive landscape!!! | Reply
  • joe (31 July 2009 09:20)
    If they perform the same test on nano which manufactured for india i dont think it perform in a same way as shown in video...... | Reply
  • joe (30 July 2009 23:49)
    guys, easy now, nobody really crashes at 48 or 55.. in real life it mostly happens in misread overtaking maneuvers and at blind crossings and in the average pre-crash speeds in accidents survival of any of the cars in the immediate spectrum of reference (indica, marutis, hyundais etc) is only limited to the occupants luck. So these tests are like your brochure 'test conditions'.. of performance and mileage claims. I have seen two dimensional salvage pieces of popular car models and it makes me shudder while speeding. | Reply
  • Bhavin (30 July 2009 22:44)
    Bravo, marvellous. Tata knew that it wanted to sell nano in U.S | Reply
  • Ninad (30 July 2009 18:37)
    i m abs proud of the Nano passing these tests, but the concern remains with the light weight. If you watch the last part, the car bounces and flies outta track,which could be fatal when hit again. Gone are those days where you could compare with Maruti 800, its time to compare Nano with the Merc Smart or For Two, I hope Tatas can upgrade Nano with tech from Jags. | Reply
  • Akash (30 July 2009 18:12)
    I think people don't understand safety norms...tht is why they talk all this nonosense...is a Maruti Omni safe? the damn thing has been the reason for a many a person to loose a life...just a sheet of tin between you and whatever you crash into.....If Tata is taking the time and money to make the Nano safe...why can't people feel that this is a reason to be proud...why call out and say Indian nano is not safe....get a life ....or are we just a land of people who just love to crib all the time....we try and find fault with everything..... | Reply
  • Ravi Shankar (30 July 2009 17:14)
    Before critisizing anybody why can't reader understand the meaning of what is written in the aritcle, it is clearly mentioned that all modification required after the test are being incorporated in the INDIAN version also. Than where is the question of quality difference between the cars to be marketed in UK or INDIA. | Reply
  • asdhinv (30 July 2009 15:56)
    people just criticized and criticized that the Nano is not safe etc. as if the maruti suzukii cars which indians are driving since 1983 were safe. People in India are just so hypocritical they would drive a cheap maruti and would go ga-ga over it. But they would say anything coming from the TATA is cheap.What a rubbish attitude towards our own India company. Instead of supporting suzuki which gives cheap products and who is not at all selling in the rest of the world Indians should support Tata | Reply
  • raju (30 July 2009 15:38)
    I was looking forward to this news and details of crash test of Nano. Hats off to the engineers and team worked towards this Valuable car from TATA group that is known for values and serving the nation. | Reply
  • asitabh (30 July 2009 15:17)
    Its good to hear this :) | Reply
  • Yogendra (30 July 2009 15:15)
    Tata Nano is a miracle | Reply
  • Kapil Mishra (30 July 2009 14:11)
    Good to see the Tatas lead on the safety front but I do hope they also brush up their customer service behaviour which many a while leaves a lot to be desired. Safety is something we Indians do not ever consider as much as fuel efficiency so it is heartening that the nano scores large on both counts. | Reply
  • Hridesh (30 July 2009 12:23)
    To all you people out there who are speaking off the hat without knowing the fine details.... Please note that the Indian version of the Nano has already complied and passed the Indian Safety norms. I think that is a pretty good story so far for the Tata Nano. The problem is critics want to "believe" that Nano is a useless car, but the truth is that it is an engineering marvel. Cheers to Tata and Cheers to Nano. | Reply
  • Jehan A D (30 July 2009 12:08)
    This is for Jit Piplani, Sam and Sunil, do read everything correctly and not selectively. The difference between the tests for India and the UK is 8 km/h. The Indian tests specify a speed at point of impact to be 48km/h while the European levels are 56km/h. Also do note that the BIW structural bits added for this test get affixed at the assembly line stage so the Nano which already meets the Indian crash test legislation would also get them. Guys before someone hits you with a bicycle for wrong inference, do yourself a favour and stay safe by reading correctly. And this is specifically for you Sunil, your inference is probably the most hilarious of the lot when you say because these modifications aren't there on the Indian Nano the car is unsafe, how about you reading correctly that the cars had already been crash tested to our levels? Probably the best thing you can do is to stay safe and cocooned in the safety of your four walls. | Reply
  • Rohit (30 July 2009 10:02)
    I thought it was a crash with Bicycle !!!!!!!! | Reply
  • Sunil (30 July 2009 09:53)
    it would have been better if the Indian Nano had met these crash standards. If u read, it is mentioned that certain modifications were made to the Nano before it wa subjected to the tests. now had these modifications been made to the Indian Nano then the price would have gone up. so it means that the Nanos seen on Indian roads are not that safe! | Reply
  • VIJAY KIUMAR KVD (30 July 2009 08:25)
    Its rocking to see that TATA's NANO is catching world attention . | Reply
  • N Kirgi (30 July 2009 08:24)
    At least Maruti should learn something from TATA and stop producing Maruti 800 and Alto which are death on wheels. Thank God that they atleast phased out Zen. | Reply
  • jit piplani (30 July 2009 06:19)
    carry out this test on the indian version to claim it is a tough cookie!! | Reply
  • SAM (29 July 2009 22:16)
    TATA NANO for UK is a different car for UK ,THE INDIAN VERSION WAS NOT USED FOR THIS TEST,the test was made for the UK VERSION in the UK.,., even the VISTA is short of any safety features. | Reply
Comment on this article
*Mandatory
*Your Comment :
*Your Name :
*Your E-mail :
*Word Verification :
Letters are case-sensitive

Top News

Ford to export Figo to 50 new markets
Hyundai Santa Fe to be launched in October
Nissan to take booking of Leaf Reuters
A-Star AT vs. i10 Magna 1.2 Kappa AT
Electrified!
  Archives>>




All entries are compulsory
Your Question
Your Name
Your E-mail

Shop @ Zigwheels.com
Car Audio Mobile Accessories Other Accessories Car Perfumes Car video Accessories Toy Cars Cleaning products
Hot on Zigwheels
Tips for safe driving
Tips for safe driving and more...
Safety is one of the most essential factors...
 Tackling the Monsoon
 Tips for Long drive
 Child Attention!
 Winter Driving tips
More...
ENVIROMENTAL CORNER
ENVIROMENTAL CORNER
The world is facing a severe fuel crisis...
 Ways to save fuel
 Why buy Hybrids car
 Ways to Drive Green
More...
 
 
MAINTENANCE CORNER
MAINTENANCE CORNER SPECIAL PACKAGE
A vehicle that is maintained well will...
 Tips to run your car
 Engine Care Tips
 Tips for the Service Center
 Interior Detailing
More...
GADGETS CORNER
GADGETS CORNER
From gizmos to apparel with an automotive...
 Apparel
 Accessories
 Other Stuff
More...
 
 
Join Our Zigwheels Community on: orkut facebook
August 2010 Calendars
Land Rovers Kawasaki ZX-10R
Land Rovers
Kawasaki ZX-10R
  Wallpaper   Wallpaper
  Printable   Printable
Most Viewed new cars on Zigwheels
New Car
More: Delhi | Mumbai | Bangalore
Subscribe:  Rss Feed
Most Viewed used cars on Zigwheels
Used Car
More: Delhi | Mumbai | Bangalore
Copyright ©2010 Times Internet Limited. All rights reserved. Advertise with us  |  Careers @ TIL |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy  |  Sitemap  |  Contact us